- Onsite training
3,000,000+ delegates
15,000+ clients
1,000+ locations
- KnowledgePass
- Log a ticket
01344203999 Available 24/7
ISO 9001 Internal Audit Sample Questions
Explore the ISO 9001 Internal Audit Sample Questions for conducting internal audits. Dive into the questions related to understanding ISO 9001 requirements, risk-based thinking, and the context of the organisation. These questions will help auditors and organisations ensure their Quality Management Systems (QMS).
Exclusive 40% OFF
Training Outcomes Within Your Budget!
We ensure quality, budget-alignment, and timely delivery by our expert instructors.
Share this Resource
- ISO 9001 lead implementer certification
- ISO 9001 Internal Auditor Training
- ISO 9001 Lead Auditor Course
According to ISO , the U.K. stands in the top 5 countries with 39,682 ISO 9001 Certificates in 2022. Further, this blog will comprehensively list updated ISO 9001 Internal Audit Sample Questions. These questions will help Auditors and organisations ensure their Quality Management Systems (QMS) are robust, effective, and aligned with the latest ISO 9001 Requirements .
Table of Contents
1) Questions on Understanding ISO 9001 requirements
2) Risk-based Thinking and Context of the Organisation Questions
3) Questions on Leadership and Commitment in Internal Audit
4) Questions on Planning and Objectives in Internal Audit
5) Questions on Operation and performance evaluation
6) Conclusion
Questions on Understanding ISO 9001 Requirements
Here are some basic questions on ISO 9001:
1) What is the Purpose of ISO 9001, and How Does it Benefit Organisations?
ISO 9001 is a recognised standard for QMS. Its primary purpose remains consistent: Helping organisations achieve consistent quality while adapting to contemporary business dynamics. The benefits have evolved to align with modern demands.
ISO 9001 benefits organisations by enhancing competitiveness and resilience while adhering to ISO 9001 Principles . It promotes customer-centricity, ensuring that products and services meet or exceed customer expectations, which is crucial for fostering loyalty and revenue growth in an era driven by customer satisfaction.
2) How Does ISO 9001 Define the Scope of the QMS?
ISO 9001 defines the content of the QMS by specifying the products, services, and processes it covers specifying the difference between ISO 9001 vs Six Sigma with its focus on statistical analysis and process improvement techniques . A clear scope ensures that quality efforts are focused where they matter most, aligning with customer needs and organisational goals.
The scope statement should consider the organisation's size, complexity, and stakeholder expectations. It must align with strategic objectives, ensuring the QMS contributes directly to business success through expansion, cost reduction, or sustainability.
3) What are the Key Clauses and Sections of the ISO 9001 Standard?
ISO 9001 comprises essential clauses and sections, including:
ISO 9001 comprises essential clauses and sections:
a) Scope : Defines the QMS boundaries
b) Normative references : Lists external ISO Quality Standards referenced
c) Terms and definitions : Provides term definitions
d) Context of the Organisation : Considers internal and external context
e) Leadership : Emphasises leadership's role in QMS
f) Planning : Focuses on risk assessment, objectives, and action plans
g) Support : Addresses resource management and communication
h) Operation : Covers operational planning and control
i) Performance Evaluation : Details monitoring and analysis processes
j) Improvement : Encourages continual QMS enhancement
Risk-based Thinking and Context of the Organisation Questions
Here are some ISO 9001 audit sample questions on risk-based thinking and the context of the organisation
1) How Does ISO 9001 Emphasise the Importance of Risk-based Thinking in Quality Management?
ISO 9001 emphasises the importance of risk-based thinking by requiring organisations to identify and evaluate risks and opportunities that could affect the organisation's ability to meet its quality objectives. This means that organisations need to identify potential problems and take steps to mitigate them proactively. Risk-based thinking is also essential for identifying and taking advantage of opportunities to improve the organisation's performance.
2) What Steps Should an Organisation Take to Identify and Assess Risks and Opportunities in its Context?
The following are some steps that an organisation can take to identify and assess risks and opportunities in its context:
a) Understand the organisation's context, including its internal and external environment.
b) Identify and assess all risks and opportunities that could affect the organisation's ability to meet its quality objectives.
c) Prioritise the risks and opportunities for treatment.
d) Implement appropriate controls to mitigate the risks and take advantage of the opportunities.
3) How can an Internal Auditor Ensure That an Organisation Effectively Implements Risk-based Thinking?
An Internal Auditor can ensure that an organisation effectively implements risk-based thinking by:
a) Reviewing the organisation's Risk Management Process to ensure that it is aligned with the requirements of ISO 9001
b) Evaluating the effectiveness of the organisation's risk controls
c) Making recommendations for improvement to the organisation's Risk Management process
Empower your organi sation with ISO 9001 compliance - become a certified Internal Auditor with ISO 9001 Internal Audit or Course !
Questions on Leadership and Commitment in Internal Audit
Here are some questions on leadership and commitment in Internal Audit:
1) What are the Leadership Responsibilities According to ISO 9001?
The leadership responsibilities according to ISO 9001 are:
a) Be a role model for others in the organisation by demonstrating your commitment to quality
b) Ensure that the QMS is aligned with the organisation's strategic direction
c) Promote a culture of continuous improvement
d) Provide resources for the QMS
e) Communicate the importance of the QMS to all employees
f) Promote the involvement of all employees in the QMS
g) Ensure that the QMS is effective and efficient
h) Review the QMS regularly and make improvements as needed
2) How Can an Auditor Evaluate Top Management's Commitment to the QMS?
An Auditor can evaluate top management's commitment to the QMS by:
a) Reviewing the organisation's quality policy and objectives
b) Observing the behaviour of top management
c) Interviewing top management and other employees
d) Reviewing the organisation's ISO 9001 Documentation
3) What Evidence Should be Sought to Determine if Leadership Effectively Supports the QMS?
The following is some evidence that an Auditor should seek to determine if leadership effectively supports the QMS:
a) The organisation has a documented quality policy and objectives that are aligned with the organisation's strategic direction.
b) Top management is actively involved in the QMS
c) Top management provides the necessary resources for the QMS.
d) Top management communicates the importance of the QMS to all employees.
e) Top management promotes the involvement of all employees in the QMS.
f) The organisation has a process for reviewing the QMS regularly and making improvements as needed.
Join now in our ISO 9001 Lead Auditor Training to enhance your auditing skills and advance your professional journey!
Questions on Planning and Objectives in Internal Audit
Here are some questions on planning and objectives in Internal Audit:
1) What Does the ISO 9001 Standard Require Regarding Planning and Setting Quality Objectives?
The ISO 9001 Standard requires organisations to plan their QMS and set quality objectives that are:
a) Specific: The goals should be unambiguous
b) M easurable: The goals should be quantifiable or measurable to track progress
c) A chievable: Given the organisation's resources and capabilities, the objectives should be realistic and achievable
d) Relevant: The purposes should be relevant to the organisation's strategic goals and objectives
e) Time-bound: The purposes should have a specific timeframe for completion
2) How Can an Internal Auditor Assess if the Organisation's Objectives are Based on SMART Goals?
An Internal Auditor can assess if the organisation's objectives are based on SMART goals by:
b) Interviewing the organisation's management and employees
c) Reviewing the organisation's documentation
d) The auditor should seek evidence from the ISO 9001 Audit Checklist
3) What Role Does the Quality Policy Play in the Planning Process?
The quality policy is a statement of the organisation's commitment to quality. It provides the foundation for the planning process by setting out the organisation's overall goals and objectives for quality. The quality policy should be communicated to all employees to guide the planning process.
Questions on Operation and Performance Evaluation
Here are some questions on operation and performance evaluation :
1) What are the Critical Components of the ISO 9001 Standard Related to Product and Service Provision?
The critical components of the ISO 9001 Standard related to product and service provision are:
a) Planning and control of production and service provision
b) Identification and management of customer property
c) Preservation of product and service conformity
d) Control of monitoring and measuring devices
2) How Can an Internal Auditor Assess the Effectiveness of Processes and Controls?
An Internal Auditor can assess the effectiveness of processes and controls by:
a) Reviewing the organisation's documentation
c) Observing the organisation's operations
d) Reviewing the organisation's data and records
3) What Performance Indicators Should an Auditor Consider When Evaluating the QMS's Performance?
The performance indicators that an ISO 9001 Auditor should consider when evaluating the QMS's performance include:
a) Customer satisfaction
b) Number of defects
c) Employee training and competence
d) Cost of quality
e) Employee satisfaction
Empower your team with ISO 9001 Training for enhanced Quality Management and organisational excellence. Join today!
Conclusion
Staying informed about the latest ISO 9001 Standards and Internal Audit practices is paramount for organisations committed to Quality Management. These updated ISO 9001 Internal Audit Sample Questions provide a valuable tool for Auditors and businesses to ensure compliance, drive improvement, and meet customer expectations effectively.
Begin your journey towards ISO 9001 excellence by joining our ISO 9001 Foundation Course today!
Frequently Asked Questions
To conduct an internal audit for ISO 9001, first, plan the audit by defining its scope and objectives. Next, prepare audit checklists based on ISO 9001 requirements. Then, perform the audit by reviewing documents, observing processes, and interviewing staff.
Internal Auditors need analytical skills to assess processes and identify risks, attention to detail to ensure accuracy in their reviews, communication skills to effectively report findings, problem-solving abilities to recommend improvements, and knowledge of relevant standards and regulations, such as ISO 9001 to ensure compliance.
The Knowledge Academy takes global learning to new heights, offering over 30,000 online courses across 490+ locations in 220 countries. This expansive reach ensures accessibility and convenience for learners worldwide.
Alongside our diverse Online Course Catalogue, encompassing 17 major categories, we go the extra mile by providing a plethora of free educational Online Resources like News updates, Blogs , videos, webinars, and interview questions. Tailoring learning experiences further, professionals can maximise value with customisable Course Bundles of TKA .
The Knowledge Academy’s Knowledge Pass , a prepaid voucher, adds another layer of flexibility, allowing course bookings over a 12-month period. Join us on a journey where education knows no bounds.
The Knowledge Academy offers various ISO 9001 Certification Courses , including the ISO 9001 Foundation Course, and the ISO 9001 Lead Auditor Course. These courses cater to different skill levels, providing comprehensive insights into Roles and Responsibilities of ISO 9001 Auditor .
Our ISO and Compliance Blogs cover a range of topics related to ISO 9001, offering valuable resources, best practices, and industry insights. Whether you are a beginner or looking to advance your ISO and Compliance knowledge, The Knowledge Academy's diverse courses and informative blogs have got you covered.
Upcoming Business Improvement Resources Batches & Dates
Mon 14th Oct 2024
Mon 11th Nov 2024
Mon 16th Dec 2024
Mon 6th Jan 2025
Mon 3rd Feb 2025
Mon 3rd Mar 2025
Mon 7th Apr 2025
Mon 12th May 2025
Mon 2nd Jun 2025
Mon 7th Jul 2025
Mon 4th Aug 2025
Mon 1st Sep 2025
Mon 20th Oct 2025
Mon 3rd Nov 2025
Mon 1st Dec 2025
Get A Quote
WHO WILL BE FUNDING THE COURSE?
My employer
By submitting your details you agree to be contacted in order to respond to your enquiry
- Business Analysis
- Lean Six Sigma Certification
Share this course
Our biggest summer sale.
We cannot process your enquiry without contacting you, please tick to confirm your consent to us for contacting you about your enquiry.
By submitting your details you agree to be contacted in order to respond to your enquiry.
We may not have the course you’re looking for. If you enquire or give us a call on 01344203999 and speak to our training experts, we may still be able to help with your training requirements.
Or select from our popular topics
- ITIL® Certification
- Scrum Certification
- ISO 9001 Certification
- Change Management Certification
- Microsoft Azure Certification
- Microsoft Excel Courses
- Explore more courses
Press esc to close
Fill out your contact details below and our training experts will be in touch.
Fill out your contact details below
Thank you for your enquiry!
One of our training experts will be in touch shortly to go over your training requirements.
Back to Course Information
Fill out your contact details below so we can get in touch with you regarding your training requirements.
* WHO WILL BE FUNDING THE COURSE?
Preferred Contact Method
No preference
Back to course information
Fill out your training details below
Fill out your training details below so we have a better idea of what your training requirements are.
HOW MANY DELEGATES NEED TRAINING?
HOW DO YOU WANT THE COURSE DELIVERED?
Online Instructor-led
Online Self-paced
WHEN WOULD YOU LIKE TO TAKE THIS COURSE?
Next 2 - 4 months
WHAT IS YOUR REASON FOR ENQUIRING?
Looking for some information
Looking for a discount
I want to book but have questions
One of our training experts will be in touch shortly to go overy your training requirements.
Your privacy & cookies!
Like many websites we use cookies. We care about your data and experience, so to give you the best possible experience using our site, we store a very limited amount of your data. Continuing to use this site or clicking “Accept & close” means that you agree to our use of cookies. Learn more about our privacy policy and cookie policy cookie policy .
We use cookies that are essential for our site to work. Please visit our cookie policy for more information. To accept all cookies click 'Accept & close'.
The Auditor
An exemplar global publication.
- Defining Good Governance: A Critical Step Towards Sustainable Development
- Resilience through Alliances: Building Climate Adaptation
- Why Indoor Farmers Need SQF Certification
- Certified SQF Practitioner Credential
- Common Pitfalls in ISMS Risk Assessment and How to Avoid Them
- Achieving Active Wisdom in Your Career
- The Baltimore Bridge Collapse—Another Case of a Failed Management System
- Webinar Preview—Staying Compliant: Considering Climate Change in ISO Management Systems
- Profile: John O’Connell
- A Quick 10-Point Checklist for Managing Risks to Food Safety in a Storage & Distribution Environment
The Seven Most Important ISO 9001:2015 Audit Questions
Editor’s Note: This piece first appeared in 2016 and has proven to be one of the most popular articles we have ever published here on The Auditor Online . Do you feel that Craig Cochran’s advice still holds up after several years? What questions, if any, have emerged since then that should be included on this list? Please add your comments below and we’ll craft a follow-up article based on this feedback.
By Craig Cochran
If you’re preparing to start auditing to ISO 9001:2015, you’ve probably already asked yourself the timeless question: “What in the heck am I going to ask these people?” There’s no worse feeling in the world than being in the middle of an audit and realizing that you’ve run out of questions. Preparation and planning can remedy this, of course, but the fact remains that ISO 9001:2015 includes a lot of new requirements that have never been part of most audits. To help prepare you for auditing to ISO 9001:2015, I’ve prepared a list of what I consider to be the seven most important audit questions for ISO 9001:2015:
1. What can you tell me about the context of your organization?
This question is the starting point of ISO 9001:2015, appearing in clause 4.1. The standard uses the clunky term “context,” but this could easily be substituted by asking about the organization’s internal and external success factors. Questions about context are usually directed at top management or the person leading the quality management system (QMS)–formerly known as the management representative. As an auditor, you’re looking for a clear examination of forces at work within and around the organization. Does this sound broad and a little vague? It is. Thankfully, the standard provides some guidance, saying that context must include internal and external issues that are relevant to your organization’s purpose, strategy, and QMS goals. Many organizations will probably use a SWOT (strengths, weaknesses, opportunities, and threats) analysis to help get their arms around context, but it’s not a requirement. What the organization learns with this will be a key input to risk analysis. (Note: Not everybody will understand the term “context.” Be prepared to discuss the concept and describe what ISO 9001:2015 is asking for.)
2. Who are your interested parties and what are their requirements?
The natural follow-up to context is interested parties, found in clause 4.2. Just like context, interested parties are a key input to risk. The term “interested parties” has a bizarre, stalker-like ring to it, so smart auditors might want to replace it with “stakeholders.” Remember, effective auditors try to translate the arcane language of ISO 9001:2015 into understandable terms that auditees can grasp. Typical interested parties include employees, customers, suppliers, business owners, debt holders, neighbors, and regulators.
As an auditor, you’re making sure that a reasonable range of interested parties has been identified, along with their corresponding requirements. The best way to audit this is an exploratory discussion. Ask questions about the interested parties, and probe what they’re interested in. If you’ve done some preparation in advance of the audit, you’ll know whether their examination of interested parties is adequate.
This brings up an important planning issue: You’ll have to do a bit more preparation before an ISO 9001:2015 audit. Why? So you’ll have a grasp of context and interested parties. How can you evaluate their responses if you don’t know what the responses should be?
3. What risks and opportunities have been identified, and what are you doing about them?
Risks and opportunities could accurately be called the foundation of ISO 9001:2015. No fewer than 13 other clauses refer directly to risks and opportunities, making them the most “connected” section of the standard. If an organization does a poor job of identifying risks and opportunities, then the QMS cannot be effective, period.
Auditors should verify that risks and opportunities include issues that focus on desired outcomes, prevent problems, and drive improvement. Once risks and opportunities are identified, actions must be planned to address them. ISO 9001:2015 doesn’t specifically mention prioritizing risks and opportunities, though it would be wise for organizations to do this. Risks and opportunities are limitless, but resources are not.
4. What plans have been put in place to achieve quality objectives?
Measurable quality objectives have long been a part of ISO 9001. What’s new is the requirement to plan actions to make them happen. The plans are intended to be specific and actionable, addressing actions, resources, responsibilities, timeframes, and evaluation of results. Auditors should closely examine how the plans have been implemented throughout the organization and who has knowledge of them. Just as employees should be aware of how they contribute to objectives, they should be familiar with the action plans.
5. How has the QMS been integrated into the organization’s business processes?
In other words, how are you using ISO 9001:2015 to help you run the company? This is asked directly of top management (see subclause 5.1.1c) and is a very revealing question. The point is that ISO 9001 is moving away from being a quality management system standard and becoming a strategic management system. It’s not just about making sure products or services meet requirements anymore. The standard is about managing every aspect of the business. Remember clauses 4.1 and 4.2 of ISO 9001:2015? They examine the key topics of context and interested parties. These concepts touch every corner of the organization, and this is exactly how ISO 9001:2015 is intended to be used. Top management should be able to describe how the QMS is used to run the company, not just pass an audit.
6. How do you manage change?
This topic comes up multiple times in ISO 9001:2015. The first and biggest clause on the topic is clause 6.3, Planning of changes. Here we identify changes that we know are coming and develop plans for their implementation. What kind of changes? Nearly anything, but the following changes come to mind as candidates: new or modified products, processes, equipment, tools, employees, regulations. The list is endless. An auditor should review changes that took place and seek evidence that the changes were identified and planned proactively.
Change that happens in a less planned manner is addressed in subclause 8.5.6. Here the auditor will seek records that the changes met requirements, the results of reviewing changes, who authorized them, and subsequent actions that were necessary.
7. How do you capture and use knowledge?
ISO 9001:2015 wants organizations to learn from their experiences, both good and bad. This could be handled by a variety of means: project debriefs, job close-outs, staff meetings, customer reviews, examination of data, and customer feedback. How the organization captures knowledge is up to it, but the process should be clear and functional. The knowledge should also be maintained and accessible. This almost sounds like it will be “documented” in some way, doesn’t it? That’s exactly right. One way to audit this would be to inquire about recent failures or successes. How did the organization learn from these events in a way that will help make it more successful? It’s the conversion of raw information to true knowledge, and it just happens to be one of the most difficult things an organization can achieve.
These are by no means the only questions you’ll want to ask. They’re just the starting point. I didn’t even mention management review, corrective action, or improvement—all of which are crucial to an effective QMS. The seven topics discussed here are the biggest new requirements that auditors need to probe. I would be very interested in hearing from you on this subject. What audit questions do you see as critical in ISO 9001:2015? Please leave your comments below.
About the author
Craig Cochran is the North Metro Regional Manager with Georgia Tech’s Economic Development Institute. He has assisted more than 5,000 companies since 1999 in QMS implementation, problem solving, auditing, and performance improvement. Cochran is a Certified Quality Manager, Certified Quality Engineer, and Certified Quality Auditor through the American Society for Quality. He is certified as a QMS Lead Auditor through Exemplar Global.
He is the author of numerous books, including the newly released ISO 9001:2015 in Plain English , published by Paton Professional .
59 Responses
Hi Craig I would appreciate the ISO 9001 and 14001-2015 check lists. Kindly advise the costs if any have a great day Best Regards Mike Bird
Excellent article. One comment though, to me context is the external and internal “pressures” on the organization and what they do to counter act or respond to these. For example, customers put certain pressures on an organization. What does the organization do because of their customers?
Great ideas for thought
Good listicle, enjoying the book. Kudos Craig!
Craig – thanks for an informative post. As always, appreciate your insights!
Excellent article. Is there a checklist that can be used for internal audits on ISO 9001 : 2015 and ISO 14001 : 2015 ?
This is a great article, interesting reading If possible, where can we obtain checklists for the new standards?
Excellent article adding a new dimension to some of the basic questions used to ascertain where an organisation is at.
Same request is there a checklist and if so may I obtain one? I am concerned about acceptable evidence for the new 9001:2015.
How are these executive level discussions handled in terms of audit nonconformances? If the auditor determines in his/her view that the performance is ineffective, how is that documented as “major” or “minor” nonconformances, and is it not open to debate? How are the auditors trained to have these executive level conversations and make these judgments?
Very apt and insightful questions. Will no doubt ensure value added audit process.
1.to answer Q7 about capturing and maintaining knowledge in the organisation one can refer to Cl 7.1.6-organisation knowledge. 2. For other Questions too author can put the relevant sections of ISO 9001:2015 overall excellent coverage for beginners.
Excellent article. It would be appropriate to also include a question about how the organization has internalized the new term of 7.5 documented information. Best Regards. Víctor Quispe. Lima-Perú.
Very good article. Is there a checklist? May I receive one?
Dear Craig I trust you are well? I requested some information on January 27th 2016-kindly refer to the first [1st] of eleven responses above. Any luck/information or Joy related to this request. Have a great day and Best Regards Mike Bird Fellow and Foundation Member of QSA + 61 408 566 037
Please provide knowledge on: OFI (Opportunities For Improvement) Standard Reference: ISO 9001: 2015 (Clause wise)
Thanks & Regards, Rajeswar Bomma
Hi Craig I would appreciate the ISO 9001 and 14001-2015 check lists. Kindly advise. Have a great day Best Regards David.Thia
Great article where can one find a free 9001:2015 Audit Checklist?
Great info! Same request is there a 9001:2015 Audit Checklist and if so may I obtain one?
hi thanks for describe the requirements of 9001. may i have example for the organizational knowledge and audit check list?
I need one sample good iso 9001 2015 audit report
good and well checklist of iso 9001 2015
Thank you so much, its so much helpful
Thank you Craig. I have your book, ” ISO 9001: 2015 in Plain English” . Well explained. I want to get in touch with you. Can you please share your mail id ?
Can you please share some examples for Audit exercises? (These can be used for training)
That exercise should contain the observation by Auditor and from there we need to identify the Non-Conformities mentioning ISO 9001:2015 clauses.
Thank you once again.
Sorry….these are not the most important questions!
These will get you less than half the picture of whether a QMS is healthy, robust and functioning as intended!
Very informative write up, indeed. Some of the new requirements, such as knowledge base is very deep and value meaning for the organizations. Even a century ago a few organizations avoided trap of “not reinventing the wheel” (inefficiency) by keeping well structured documents (design, amendments, corrections, improvement etc.) so now a days having information technology, data bases, server etc. retaining and protecting information is not a big issue it used to be. However, the structure of the information is key and it is an art form known to a few not many.
Well Done Craig! Definitely using this article as a fantastic reference – thanks!
It is most asked question. Thank for sharing very informative and fantastic article.
hi admin , Nice article where can one find a free 9001:2015 standard Audit- Checklist?
Thank you for your writting! It is easy to understand and detailed. I feel it is interesting, I hope you continue to have such good posts.
Very nice questions for auditing top management!
Subjective Assignment
1.Read and understand the following scenario given below; Based on the scenario, state the Non conformity (NC) and mention the NC clause. State whether it is a major or minor Non conformity. Write the Objective evidence for Non conformity. The supplier development process, “Materials approval on the incoming inspection,” is out of control. Further investigation showed that the major problems were with new suppliers that were selected without any manufacturing site audit, as stated in the supplier development procedure in P7.1, Revision C. According to the purchasing manager, this problem happened because they did not have time to evaluate suppliers in the latest product development.
Enter your answer
Thanks for Sharing Information about ISO 9001 Certification!
Appreciate the time you spend in sharing your knowledge and understanding of these standards. There is always something new for us to learn.
Hi craig this article superb . Is there a checklist that can be used for internal audits on ISO 9001 : 2015 and there relevant clause in all the department ? At least for fresher
Excellent articles
Good Informative. Thanks for sharing it.
FOR ALLCLAUSES
Thanks for ” theauditoronline ” team. shre for this valuable article. all information is very usefull.
its really helpful
https://qsafe.com.qa/iso-certification-training/
As an ISO 9001 Lead Auditor, i can relate to it, thank you.
Mastering the seven key audit questions for ISO 9001:2015 ensures Saudi Arabian businesses meet stringent quality standards, essential for ISO Certification. Strengthen your auditing expertise to drive excellence and compliance in the Saudi market.
Thank you for sharing your thoughts, Maxiert!
Insightful read! As an ISO Certification enthusiast in Saudi Arabia, these audit questions provide valuable guidance for ensuring compliance and continuous improvement
Good to know it’s helpful! Thank you for your feedback, Maxicert!
I’ll definitely be sharing this article with my friends and colleagues. It’s too good not to pass along!
Home Page: https://popularcert.com/
Visit our link for ISO Certification In Saudi Arabia: https://popularcert.com/locations/iso-certification-in-saudi-arabia/
Thank you for your feedback, ISO Popularcert!
Efficiency is a key component of our certification services. We recognize that time is a critical factor for businesses, and we are committed to helping you achieve certification in the shortest possible timeframe
Thank you for sharing your thoughts, Popularcert!
Great post! You are awesome! I really enjoy your writing and love the topic. I hope to see more posts from you in the future. Thank you!
Thank you for sharing this valuable information! Your post is greatly appreciated and significantly enriches our knowledge base.
Software Training Institute in Bangalore
Such nice helpful content.
Thank you so much for such a well-written article. It’s full of insightful information.
This is an excellent blog! It’s really useful for me, and I appreciate you sharing this informative content. Please keep updating your blog.
I’m really impressed with the content presented here. It’s not only informative but also highly relevant to my interests. I found it incredibly useful, offering insights that I hadn’t considered before. The way the information is laid out makes it easy to understand, and I genuinely enjoyed reading it. I always appreciate blogs that provide this level of value, and I look forward to reading more content like this in the future.
Leave a Reply Cancel Reply
This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed .
Become a certified CQI IRCA Certified Lead Auditor with our top notch ISO 9001 QMS , 14001 EMS , and 45001 OHSMS courses. Enroll now!
- ISO 45001 OHSMS Lead Auditor Training
- Course Calendar
- Partner with us
ISO 9001 Lead Auditor Sample Exam Questions and Answers
Cqi irca certified iso 9001 lead auditor sample exam questions and answers.
To successfully complete CQI IRCA Certified ISO 9001 QMS Lead Auditor course , learners must pass both the continuous evaluation and the final examination.
1. Continuous Evaluation
It is a formative assessment that will be held throughout the 5 days course. You will undergo audit activities, and be provided daily feedback on your progress which will help you increase your knowledge in performing audits. The activities of each delegate are graded by the tutor. You need to successfully complete all the activities and score a minimum passing grade in the continuous evaluation .
2. Final Examination
Here are some of the key details you need to know before appearing for the final examination.
1. The duration of the exam is 120 Minutes, however, if you are a non-native speaker you will be given an extra 24 Minutes in addition to the 120 Minutes.
2. The exam is conducted both in class or online depending on the mode of your training. (3FOLD Training conducts the entire training and the final exam online )
3. The only resource that you can use during the exam is the relevant ISO Scheme standard ISO 9001:2015. It is not permissible to use ISO 19011 standard.
4. English dictionary is allowed, however, it is not found useful by many of the participants.
ISO 9001 Lead Auditor Sample Exam Questions and Answers:
There are 4 sections in the ISO 9001 QMS Lead Auditor examination as illustrated in table 1 below. In this ISO 9001 lead auditor sample exam questions and answer article, we will examine one question per section and provide their answers.
In table 1 you can find the question break-ups and the passing scores.
Table 1: ISO 9001 Exam Section and Question break-up
1 | 5 | 4.5 | 10 |
2 | 4 | 9.5 | 20 |
3 | 3 | 14.5 | 30 |
4 | 3 | 14.5 | 30 |
Table 1 shows us the total available and minimum marks to pass each section. It is mandatory to pass each section. For example: if you have scored 6 marks on section 1, 18 marks on section 2, 10 marks on section 3 & 30 marks on section 4, your subtotal would be 64 marks. Though you have scored a total of 64 marks, since you haven’t scored the minimum passing marks on section 3, it will still be considered a failure.
Now let’s look at a few sample exam questions in each section.
Section 1 : This section has 5 questions and each carries 2 marks, minimum passing score on section 1 would be 4.5 marks out of 10 marks.
Sample Question: Define Process & Process Mapping. (2 marks)
Sample Answer:
Process: A set of interrelated or interacting activities which transforms inputs into outputs
Process Mapping : The purpose of process mapping is for organizations and businesses to improve efficiency
Note: CQI IRCA provides ATP a grading scheme. However, while grading the paper it is not necessary that your answer must match exactly as per the grading scheme. Trainers will use their discretion while grading the paper according to the answer you have provided. Questions that relate to identifying the clause numbers are objective in nature and should match the grading scheme.
Section 2: This section has 4 questions and each carries 5 marks, minimum passing score on section 2 would be 9.5 marks out of 20 marks.
Sample Question: Provide any five risk factors that are associated with a poorly designed audit program. (5 marks)
- Planning, e.g. failure to set relevant audit objectives;
- Resources, e.g. allowing insufficient time;
- Selection of the audit team, e.g. the team does not have the collective competence to conduct audits effectively;
- Implementation, e.g. ineffective communication of the audit program;
- Records and their controls, e.g. failure to adequately protect audit records to demonstrate audit program effectiveness;
- Monitoring, reviewing, and improving the audit program
Section 3: This section has 3 questions and each carries 10 marks, minimum passing score on section 3 would be 14.5 marks out of 30 marks.
Sample Question:
Take any organization of your choice and answer the following two questions (10 Marks)
1. Write Five Quality Objectives for an Organization (5 marks)
2. Write Five agenda items for a Management Review Meeting (5 marks)
Sample Answer A:
Note: Depending on the organization the quality objectives are set. However, there are certain basic requirements in setting up the quality objectives that will be taught in the training. Here are a few examples of the Quality Objectives of a Construction Organization mentioned in table 2 please refer.
Table 2: Quality Objectives for an Organization
Reduction of In house rejection (PPM) | 10000 | 5000 | 15.6.21 | |
Improving customer satisfaction % | 85 | 90 | 31.8.21 | |
Improving external providers performance % | 80 | 90 | 25.7.21 | |
Training Plan Vs Actual % | 90 | 95 | 31.12.21 | |
Reducing customer rejection PPM | 1200 | 500 | 31.12.21 |
Sample Answer B:
Note: Depending on the organization the meeting agenda is set. Here are a few examples of management review meeting agenda items.
a) The status of actions from previous management reviews;
b) Changes in external and Internal Issues that are relevant to the quality management system;
c) Information on the performance and effectiveness of the quality management system, including trends in:
1) customer satisfaction and feedback from relevant interested parties;
2) the extent to which quality objectives have been met;
3) process performance and conformity of products and services;
4) nonconformities and corrective action;
5) monitoring and measurement results;
6) audit results;
7) the performance of external providers;
8) the adequacy of resources;
9) the effectiveness of action taken to address risk and opportunities ;
10) opportunities for improvement.
Section 4: This section has 3 questions each carries 10 marks, minimum passing score on section 4 would be 14.5 marks out of 30 marks. (10 marks)
Questions in this section are designed to test your ability to analyze audit situations, evaluate audit evidence and apply knowledge of the audit criteria correctly.
You are required to either:
1. Complete the non-conformity report template (or) 2. Complete the audit investigation template
Depending on the case, you have to determine whether to use a non-conformity or audit investigation template.
Non-Conformity template grading rubric:
1. For correctly identifying the scenario as non-conformity (2 Marks) 2. Description of the nonconformity (3 Marks) 3. Relevant Evidence (3 Marks) 4. ISO 9001:2015 Clause and requirement (2 Marks)
Audit investigation template grading rubric:
1. Their reasons for why there is not yet sufficient evidence to report nonconformity. (2 marks) 2. Write four audit trails they would follow and specific examples of audit evidence. (8 marks)
Sample Question 1 – Case study
During a surveillance audit of JEB Manpower (a company that supplies manpower to shipping & logistic companies), it is observed that while verifying documented information in the customer complaint register, at varying occasions and ongoing for many years, workers were returned due to lack of experience and knowledge.
As an auditor, you interviewed the manager to know why this has been happening and he confirmed that he is well aware of the situation, and it is so because of insufficient funding and low profit margin. You inquired further to know what viable action has been taken to supply skilled manpower to the customer and to ensure their satisfaction. The manager replied that before sending workers to the customer, they conduct awareness training as it is economical.
Sample Answer:
Based on the given scenario, we will now see how to fill the non-conformity template.
1. You need to correctly identify the scenario as non-conformity. (2 Marks)
2. Description of the nonconformity (3 Marks)
The organization does not meet the requirements of its customer, even though the customer had complained several times.
3. Relevant Evidence (3 Marks)
The customer complaint register shows that the services provided to the customer are not meeting acceptance criteria.
4. ISO 9001:215 Clause and requirement (2 Marks)
8.5.1 Control of production and service provision The organization shall implement production and service provisions under controlled conditions. Monitor & measure activities at appropriate stages to verify that criteria for control of processes or outputs, and acceptance criteria for products and services, have been met.
Note: The QMS Exam is a closed book, only the ISO 9001:2015 standard will be allowed during your exam.
As part of the ISO 9001:2015 QMS Lead Auditor training program, participants will get a full-length specimen examination with answers and grading rubrics. This will help facilitate the preparation for the final examination. 3FOLD Training tutors can help you to understand each element of the final examination .
What if you don’t pass the final examination?
We have a stellar passing track record. In the unlikely event of you not passing the final exam, the second attempt is completely free of cost. However, this will likely change because CQI IRCA is planning to administer the exam through a third-party testing partner.
Hope this ISO 9001 Lead Auditor sample exam questions and answers article has helped to ease the tension that you may have regarding the ISO 9001 final exam and show you that with our guidance and hard work, you can pass the ISO 9001 final exam!
Why 3FOLD?
3FOLD provides world-class training resources, including mock and specimen exam patterns for ISO 9001 QMS Lead Auditor course, this will help you know the type of questions to expect in the final exam.
Interested in knowing more?
Enroll in 3FOLD ISO 9001:2015 QMS Lead Auditor Course to gain access to our Learning Management System ( LMS ) where we have more ISO 9001 Lead Auditor sample exam questions and answers to help you in your final exam.
Have questions on this topic? Contact us through the contact us form , WhatsApp , or email .
- ISO 14001:2015
- ISO 45001:2018
- ISO 9001:2015
Select course ISO 9001:2015 QMS Lead Auditor ISO 45001:2018 OHSMS Lead Auditor ISO 14001:2015 EMS Lead Auditor
You May Also Like
Benefits of ISO 9001 Internal Auditor Training Course
- June 10, 2021
ISO 9001 Lead Auditor Training Online
- June 3, 2021
Benefits of ISO 9001 Lead Auditor Training Course
- May 31, 2021
Certified Internal Auditor® (CIA®) Sample Exam Questions
Part 1 sample exam question.
According to IIA guidance, independence of the internal audit activity is achieved through which of the following?
A. Staffing and supervision. B. Continuing professional development and due professional care. C. Human relations and communications. D. Organizational status and objectivity.
A. Incorrect. Staffing and supervision relate to the professional proficiency of the internal audit activity. B. Incorrect. Continuing professional development and due professional care relate to the professional proficiency of the internal auditor. C. Incorrect. Human relations and communications relate to the professional proficiency of the internal auditor. D. Correct. According to Practice Advisory 1110-1, organizational status and objectivity permit members of the internal audit activity to render the impartial and unbiased judgments essential to the proper conduct of engagements.”
Part 2 Sample Exam Question
Considering the differences between statistical and judgmental sampling, which of the following statements about statistical sampling is true?
A. No judgment is required, because everything is computed according to a formula. B. A smaller sample can be used. C. More accurate results are obtained. D. Population estimates can be made with measurable reliability.
A. Incorrect. Judgment is needed for confidence levels and sample unit definition. B. Incorrect. A statistical sample may result in either a smaller or larger sample. C. Incorrect. There is no way to determine which method would produce greater accuracy. D. Correct. The only way to have measured reliability (stated in terms of confidence intervals) is to use a statistical sample.
Part 3 Sample Exam Question
Which of the following is the best strategy for limiting production delays caused by equipment breakdown and repair?
A. Schedule production based on capacity planning. B. Plan maintenance activity based on an analysis of equipment repair work orders. C. Preauthorize equipment maintenance and overtime pay. D. Establish a preventive maintenance program for all production equipment.
A. Incorrect. Scheduling production based on capacity utilization ignores other important factors such as demands. B. Incorrect. Budgeting maintenance department activities based on previous work orders will not prevent equipment breakdowns and repairs. C. Incorrect. Standing authorizations of work orders and overtime will not address the problem posed. D. Correct. A preventive maintenance program will reduce equipment breakdowns and repairs.
Learn about IIA programs and partners.
We are continually searching for innovative products and services to enhance our members' ability to meet their rising stakeholder demands.
- About ISO 9000 Case Studies
- Related Topics
- Standards 101
- What is ISO?
- What is ANSI?
- What are TAGS?
- What are the IEC and USNC/IEC?
- What is a Standard?
- ISO Standards Development Process
- More Standards 101
About ISO 9000
Iso 9000 resources.
- Case Studies
- Our Standards
- Z1.4 & Z1.9
ISO 9000 Related Topics
- Continuous Improvement
- Environmental Management Systems (EMS)
- History of Quality
- Plan-Do-Check-Act Cycle (PDCA)
- Process Management
- Quality Management System (QMS)
- Social Responsibility (SR)
- Statistical Sampling
- Total Quality Management (TQM)
- Quality Resources /
Quality Management Systems (QMS) & ISO 9001 – Case Studies
Implementing ISO 9001:2015 can help ensure that customers get consistent, high-quality products and services, which in turn can benefit your organization. The following ISO 9001:2015 case studies offer a look at the difference ISO 9001 can make for organizations in terms of process performance, customer satisfaction, and the bottom line.
Please note: These quality management system case studies are provided as examples of how companies have improved using ISO 9001. None of these case studies used the most recent version of the standard, ISO 9001:2015, which was released in September 2015.
ISO 9001 Case Studies
( ) Learn about a project that used an ISO 9001 approach to solidify the supply chain that provides life-saving drugs to Kenyans living with HIV/AIDS. | |
(PDF)
| |
| |
( ) | |
(PDF) | |
(PDF) | |
Do you have results to share? |
Featured Advertisers
The global body for professional accountants
- Search jobs
- Find an accountant
- Technical activities
- Help & support
Can't find your location/region listed? Please visit our global website instead
- Middle East
- Cayman Islands
- Trinidad & Tobago
- Virgin Islands (British)
- United Kingdom
- Czech Republic
- United Arab Emirates
- Saudi Arabia
- State of Palestine
- Syrian Arab Republic
- South Africa
- Africa (other)
- Hong Kong SAR of China
- New Zealand
- Our qualifications
- Getting started
- Your career
- Sign-up to our industry newsletter
- Apply to become an ACCA student
- Why choose to study ACCA?
- ACCA accountancy qualifications
- Getting started with ACCA
- ACCA Learning
- Register your interest in ACCA
- Learn why you should hire ACCA members
- Why train your staff with ACCA?
- Recruit finance staff
- Train and develop finance talent
- Approved Employer programme
- Employer support
- Resources to help your organisation stay one step ahead
- Support for Approved Learning Partners
- Becoming an ACCA Approved Learning Partner
- Tutor support
- ACCA Study Hub for learning providers
- Computer-Based Exam (CBE) centres
- ACCA Content Partners
- Registered Learning Partner
- Exemption accreditation
- University partnerships
- Find tuition
- Virtual classroom support for learning partners
- Find CPD resources
- Your membership
- Member networks
- AB magazine
- Sectors and industries
- Regulation and standards
- Advocacy and mentoring
- Council, elections and AGM
- Tuition and study options
- Study support resources
- Practical experience
- Our ethics modules
- Student Accountant
- Regulation and standards for students
- Your 2024 subscription
- Completing your EPSM
- Completing your PER
- Apply for membership
- Skills webinars
- Finding a great supervisor
- Choosing the right objectives for you
- Regularly recording your PER
- The next phase of your journey
- Your future once qualified
- Mentoring and networks
- Advance e-magazine
- Affiliate video support
- About policy and insights at ACCA
- Meet the team
- Global economics
- Professional accountants - the future
- Supporting the global profession
- Download the insights app
Can't find your location listed? Please visit our global website instead
- How to tackle audit and assurance case study questions
- Study resources
- Advanced Audit and Assurance (AAA)
- Technical articles and topic explainers
- Back to Advanced Audit and Assurance (AAA)
- How to approach Advanced Audit and Assurance
This article provides an insight into the recommended approach for Section A questions in Paper P7, Advanced Audit and Assurance . Paper P7 is one of the final options papers, and, as such, will be a demanding and challenging exam, aiming to test whether candidates have the necessary knowledge, application, skills, and judgement to complete their professional qualification. Using good exam technique and having a sensible approach to questions will do much to help secure a clear pass mark. This is the first of a two-part series on approaching Section A questions. The next article – which will be published in the September 2007 issue of student accountant – will include elements of a typical question and illustrate how these should be approached.
The exam will include two questions in Section A, with a combined mark allocation of between 50 and 70 marks. It is likely that the combined total of the two questions will be towards the higher end of this range.
Both Section A questions will be case studies. Detailed information will be provided about a business for which the candidate’s firm is providing an audit or assurance service. The aim of the case study question is to place the candidate in a real-world situation, facing the real-world requirements that an audit or assurance provider would have to deal with. The questions will therefore be practical in nature.
Case study requirements
Each case study question will include several separate requirements taken from separate syllabus areas. This mirrors what happens in the real world when, for example, an audit manager planning an assignment needs to consider not only how to plan the work, but also assess the implications of any ethical, practice management, quality control, or current professional issues raised from information provided by the client. At least one of the requirements could be to provide a response to a specific enquiry raised by the client or potential client in the scenario.
The first stage, when attempting a case study question, is to carefully read the requirements and understand exactly what is being asked for. By the time a candidate reaches this final stage in their professional studies it is hoped that they are familiar with the general style of question requirements. However, the wording used is such an important issue that it is worth repeating for the sake of clarity. At the Professional level, requirements are at the highest intellectual level and it is imperative that candidates understand exactly what is being asked.
Generally, requirements ask the candidate to perform an action, as follows:
Requirement | Meaning |
---|---|
Identify | Pick out a relevant issue/point from the scenario |
Comment on | Offer an opinion, debate a topic, express a reaction |
Explain | Clarify and provide extra details on a subject matter |
Evaluate/assess | Weigh up advantages and disadvantages and make a judgement |
Critically discuss | Consider a subject in depth and come to an opinion |
Justify | Come to a conclusion and provide a strong argument for a decision |
Candidates should familiarise themselves with exam terminology and tailor their answers accordingly. Taking time to consider the exact wording of the requirement will result in a focused answer which satisfies the question set.
Note that very few marks will be available in Paper P7 for rote-learning and the listing of facts, rules, or pieces of information. Instead, the application of knowledge to the specific scenario provided will score well. For example, a requirement may ask for the identification and explanation of matters (such as business or financial statement risks). As a general rule, a maximum of one-third of the available marks would be available for identification; the remaining two-thirds would be for the explanation of the matter. It is therefore not possible to pass the question requirement without application to the question scenario.
Professional marks
The ACCA Qualification features a core theme of ‘ethics and professionalism’, and all Professional level exams will contain some marks on this topic. In Paper P7, the professional marks will be allocated between the two Section A questions, with a maximum of five marks being available across the two questions. The requirements will clearly state how many marks are available and which question requirement they relate to.
It is likely that Section A requirements containing professional marks will ask for the answer in a particular format, such as a report or briefing notes. The professional marks will be awarded for the following:
- structure and presentation
- clarity of explanation
- use of language appropriate to the addressee
- use of professional judgement
- discussion of both sides of a debate
- appreciation of relevant current professional issues.
Case study information
Having read the requirements and understood exactly what has been asked for, the next step is to carefully read through the information provided, all the time bearing in mind the specific instructions given in the requirements.
The information provided in the scenario is likely to be both numeric and narrative, and could come from many different sources, such as:
- extracts from financial statements
- information from management systems
- details taken from working papers
- verbal representations from the client or members of the audit/assurance team
- statements from third parties.
The information in the question will need to be carefully read and it is important that sufficient time is spent digesting and understanding the information provided. Candidates who skim read the information and do not take time to stop and think about the issues raised in the scenario are likely to produce a poorly focused answer which fails to identify the main points.
When reading the case study scenario it is important, therefore, to identify the following:
- What is your role? For example, are you the manager responsible for the audit, or responsible for company-wide matters such as ethics or quality control?
- What is the time scale? Are you planning an assignment prior to the client’s year end, or reviewing working papers at the conclusion of the audit?
- What does the company do? Is it involved in manufacturing, a service industry, or financial services? Does the company operate in a highly-regulated industry?
- What is the key relationship in the scenario? Is the company a long standing or potential client? Is this a one-off or a recurring engagement?
Understanding these basic facts will ensure that candidates approach the question requirements from the correct viewpoint.
When reading through the scenario it is useful to highlight or underline important pieces of information. A lot of time can be wasted by continually re-reading the scenario, so thoroughly reading and annotating the question paper should improve time management. Remember, with reading and planning time now being given at the start of the exam, there should be plenty of time to read the entire scenario carefully.
Planning and time allocation
The case study questions will contain at least three discrete requirements. Time must be allocated between the requirements to ensure that each is addressed in sufficient depth. Failing to deal with a requirement obviously reduces the overall mark available for a question, but it also detracts from the quality of the answer as a whole. Remember, within each requirement there will be some relatively easy marks to gain, so by not attempting a requirement these marks are lost.
Is it worthwhile planning the answer? The simple answer is yes, as long as the plan is not too detailed and is then followed. A brief plan of the main points to be covered will keep the focus on the key elements of the requirements, and should avoid digressions into irrelevant matters. A good plan should prioritise the most significant issues. This is important, because if time runs short, key issues will still have been covered. A good plan will also draw out links between different pieces of information provided in the scenario. However, a plan is only worth doing if it enhances the answer. Spending too long on a very detailed plan, resulting in a lack of time to deal with the question requirements in detail, is not a good use of time in the exam. Plans should be very brief, no more than bullet points, and clearly labelled so they can not be confused with the actual answer.
A general comment on time allocation: a common error is to spend too long on the first two questions, leaving very little time for the remaining questions. It is imperative that each question is properly attempted, and that sufficient time is left towards the end of the exam to attempt the final question. Candidates are advised that the quality of the overall script will be reviewed, and students are reminded to attempt the correct number of questions.
Take time to think
This may sound obvious, but it is important to take time to think about the requirements, the scenario, and how to answer the question. Rushing to put pen to paper without sitting back to think an answer through is a frequent mistake in exams. The following are common examples of errors caused by not thinking about the facts in the scenario or the question requirement.
Failing to properly read and understand the question requirements could result in:
- not thinking properly about the actual question requirement and then proceeding to answer the requirement inappropriately. Not answering the question set is a major reason for failure. Linked to this, it is apparent that a question requirement is often only read briefly, and that the candidate then goes on to assume that the requirement is identical to requirements from previous exam questions. This will mean failing to answer the specific question set.
- making comments that belong to a different question requirement is a mistake which comes from not looking at the question requirements in their entirety. It is important to look at how the requirements relate to each other to ensure that an answer is logical and comments made do not refer to the wrong answer requirement.
Failing to read the scenario carefully, or failing to think it through, could result in:
- making inappropriate suggestions, as a result of not thinking clearly and professionally about the relationship between the audit/assurance provider and the client. It is imperative that candidates appreciate that Paper P7 examines not just technical concepts, but also the ability to make commercial and professional comments and recommendations. This is one area where stopping and thinking about the relationships between individuals within the scenario is crucial. For example, if the candidate is given the role of an audit manager or partner, it is important not to defer to more junior members of the team. Equally, inappropriate comments to the client must be avoided. For example, the management of the client company should not be ‘asked if they are corrupt’ or ‘asked to prove their technical ability to prepare accounts’. Clearly, such comments detract heavily from the quality of any answer, but can be avoided by thinking carefully about relationships and how they should be managed.
- making wholly inappropriate practical suggestions. For example, asking, as part of audit evidence, to physically verify an asset that has been sold, or requesting sight of a purchase invoice for an item bought many years ago. Think carefully about requests or recommendations and ask whether the request could actually be carried out.
- seeing a word and assuming it means something, when really it means something entirely different – this is a common mistake and results purely from not thinking before writing an answer. For example, if a scenario includes information about fines or penalties, it is important to think about whether the amount has been paid before the year end, and not to automatically assume, without taking time to think about the facts from the scenario, that a provision would be necessary.
- when performing calculations, it is crucial to think about the figures provided in the scenario and to use the correct figure in the right way. For example, when calculating materiality, make sure that the correct benchmark is used. If calculating the materiality of an asset, the materiality calculation should be based on the balance sheet, rather than on revenue as this is totally inappropriate.
Presenting the answer
It should go without saying that answers should be clearly presented, as this makes marking much easier. In particular, the following points should be noted:
- Use headings and sub-headings to give the answer a logical flow.
- Bullet points are only appropriate when listing facts which require little explanation, which will be rare in Paper P7.
- Illegible handwriting is a major problem for markers. If handwriting is a particular area of concern, leave a blank line between each line of writing, and write more slowly.
- Start each answer on a new page of the answer booklet.
Remember that some requirements contain professional marks, as discussed earlier, and in these requirements the presentation and layout of the answer is particularly important.
This article has focused on the case study questions which will appear in Section A of the Paper P7 exam, but many of the points made could equally apply to the Section B questions. It is hoped that candidates will have already developed good exam technique in order to reach this final stage in their professional exams. However, in every sitting, many relatively easy marks are not gained because of a poor approach to answering questions. It is recommended that candidates practise as many questions as possible in preparation for the exam; bearing in mind the points made in this article while practising questions should improve performance significantly.
Written by a member of the Paper P7 examining team
Related Links
- Student Accountant hub page
Advertisement
- ACCA Careers
- ACCA Career Navigator
- ACCA Learning Community
Useful links
- Make a payment
- ACCA-X online courses
- ACCA Rulebook
- Work for us
Most popular
- Professional insights
- ACCA Qualification
- Member events and CPD
- Supporting Ukraine
- Past exam papers
Connect with us
Planned system updates.
- Accessibility
- Legal policies
- Data protection & cookies
- Advertising
Top 20 Internal Audit Interview Questions & Answers
Master your responses to Internal Audit related interview questions with our example questions and answers. Boost your chances of landing the job by learning how to effectively communicate your Internal Audit capabilities.
Embarking on a career as an internal auditor means stepping into a world where attention to detail, critical thinking, and integrity are paramount. As organizations continually strive for compliance, financial accuracy, and operational efficiency, the role of an internal auditor becomes increasingly significant—and so does the interview process that leads you there.
Whether you’re new to the field or looking to advance your career, preparing for an internal audit interview requires a deep dive into not only your technical knowledge but also your ability to communicate complex information clearly and effectively. In this article, we’ll guide you through some of the most pertinent interview questions for aspiring internal auditors, offering insights on how to craft responses that demonstrate your expertise and readiness for the challenges of this meticulous profession.
Common Internal Audit Interview Questions
1. how would you assess the adequacy of our company’s risk management framework.
Understanding risk management principles and their practical application within a company’s unique context is essential for internal auditors. They must demonstrate analytical skills, familiarity with regulatory requirements, and the ability to provide actionable insights that enhance the company’s risk posture.
When responding to this question, it’s essential to articulate a methodical approach. Begin by discussing the need to review existing risk management policies and procedures, followed by evaluating how risks are currently being identified and assessed. Mention the importance of comparing the company’s practices against industry standards and best practices. Highlight your ability to engage with various stakeholders to understand their perspectives on risk and how it’s being managed. Conclude by explaining how you would report your findings and recommend improvements, ensuring that your response reflects an understanding of both the strategic and operational dimensions of risk management.
Example: “ To assess the adequacy of the company’s risk management framework, I would start by conducting a thorough review of the existing policies and procedures to ensure they are comprehensive and aligned with the company’s objectives. This would involve an evaluation of how risks are identified, categorized, and assessed in terms of likelihood and impact. I would then benchmark these practices against industry standards and regulatory requirements to identify any gaps or areas for enhancement.
Engaging with stakeholders across various levels of the organization is crucial to understand the practical application of the risk management framework and to gather insights on the effectiveness of current risk mitigation strategies. This would include discussions with the board, senior management, and operational teams. I would also analyze past incidents and how they were managed to evaluate the responsiveness and adaptability of the framework.
Upon completion of this assessment, I would compile a report detailing my findings, highlighting both the strengths and weaknesses of the current framework. This report would include pragmatic recommendations for improvement, prioritizing actions based on their potential impact on the company’s risk profile. My approach ensures a balance between strategic oversight and operational effectiveness, aiming to enhance the company’s resilience to both existing and emerging risks.”
2. Describe a time when you identified a significant control weakness within an organization.
Continuously searching for flaws that could undermine a company’s integrity, financial health, and compliance with laws and regulations is a key responsibility of internal auditors. They must be adept at identifying significant control weaknesses, which could lead to financial loss, legal issues, or damage to the organization’s reputation, and communicate these effectively to foster improvement and risk mitigation.
When responding, it’s essential to recount a specific instance that highlights your expertise in risk assessment and control evaluation. Detail the context of the control weakness, the steps taken to identify it, and the actions you recommended to address the issue. Emphasize your communication strategy with management or stakeholders, showcasing your ability to be both diplomatic and assertive, ensuring that the necessary changes were understood and implemented to strengthen the organization’s controls.
Example: “ In a recent audit, I discovered a significant control weakness in the procurement process where the segregation of duties was not properly enforced. The same individual who was authorized to create purchase orders was also responsible for approving invoices and processing payments, which exposed the organization to potential fraud risks. Upon identifying this issue, I conducted a thorough risk assessment to evaluate the potential impact and likelihood of material misstatement or fraudulent activity.
I then presented my findings to senior management, articulating the risks associated with this lack of segregation and the importance of implementing compensating controls. I recommended specific changes, including the reallocation of duties among staff and the introduction of periodic independent reviews of transactions by a separate internal team. To ensure a clear understanding and buy-in, I facilitated a workshop with the relevant stakeholders to discuss the implications and the practical steps required for remediation. The recommendations were accepted and resulted in the redesign of the procurement process, significantly mitigating the risk of fraud and enhancing the overall control environment.”
3. What steps do you take to ensure audit independence and objectivity?
Providing an unbiased viewpoint is at the heart of an internal auditor’s role, critically evaluating the efficacy of governance, risk management, and internal controls. Candidates must understand the ethical framework that guides the profession and actively implement measures to preserve their professional detachment and impartiality.
When responding, it’s crucial to articulate a clear understanding of the principles of independence and objectity. Detail the concrete steps you take, such as following established professional standards (e.g., those set by the Institute of Internal Auditors or similar bodies), ensuring a rotation of audit assignments to avoid over-familiarity, having clear reporting lines that support independence, and avoiding any conflicts of interest. You might also mention how you keep your knowledge up to date with continuous professional education to ensure your decisions are based on the most current standards and practices.
Example: “ To ensure audit independence and objectivity, I adhere strictly to the professional standards set by authoritative bodies such as the Institute of Internal Auditors. This involves maintaining an unbiased mindset and making impartial judgments, free from conflicts of interest. I ensure that all audit activities are conducted with professional skepticism, where evidence is gathered and reviewed without preconceptions about the outcome.
I support the rotation of audit assignments to mitigate the risk of over-familiarity with the areas or personnel being audited. Additionally, I advocate for clear reporting lines that reinforce the autonomy of the audit function, typically ensuring that internal audit reports to a level within the organization that allows for free and open communication and is sufficiently senior to enforce audit recommendations. Continuous professional education is a priority for me, keeping my knowledge and skills sharp to align with evolving standards and practices, which reinforces my ability to remain objective in my audit work.”
4. In what ways have you utilized data analytics during an internal audit process?
Wielding data analytics as a weapon of choice, internal auditors pinpoint anomalies, trends, and insights that influence strategic decisions. Mastery of data analytics is crucial for scrutinizing vast amounts of information efficiently and strengthening audit quality.
When responding, highlight specific instances where you’ve employed data analytics tools, such as using statistical analysis to identify outliers or trend analysis to anticipate future risks. Describe the impact your work had on the audit process, such as improved accuracy or time savings. Be prepared to explain how you ensure data integrity and confidentiality during your audits, which underscores your understanding of the responsibilities that come with handling sensitive information.
Example: “ In leveraging data analytics for internal audit, I’ve employed advanced statistical techniques to enhance the risk assessment process, enabling a more targeted audit approach. For instance, by applying predictive analytics, I was able to forecast potential areas of financial misstatement, which directed our audit focus to the highest risk transactions. This not only improved the efficiency of the audit cycle but also increased the likelihood of detecting material misstatements.
Furthermore, I’ve utilized data analytics tools to perform continuous auditing, which involved setting up automated alerts for certain risk indicators. This proactive stance allowed the internal audit function to monitor controls in real-time and address issues promptly, thus reducing the risk exposure of the organization. Throughout these processes, I ensured that data integrity was maintained by implementing stringent data validation techniques, and confidentiality was preserved through robust access controls and encryption methods.”
5. Detail your approach to conducting an audit in an area where you lack technical expertise.
Adapting, learning quickly, and leveraging resources effectively are critical when conducting an audit in an unfamiliar technical area. Auditors must demonstrate intellectual curiosity, problem-solving skills, and the ability to collaborate with experts to maintain the rigor and precision of the audit process.
When responding, outline a structured approach that begins with preliminary research to build foundational knowledge. Discuss the importance of consulting with subject matter experts and the steps taken to verify the information they provide. Highlight the use of established auditing frameworks that can be adapted to different technical scenarios and the importance of continuous learning throughout the audit process. Emphasize the value of asking the right questions, actively listening, and documenting findings meticulously. It’s also beneficial to mention any previous experiences where you successfully completed an audit in an unfamiliar domain, underscoring the strategies that led to your success.
Example: “ In approaching an audit within a domain where I lack technical expertise, I start by conducting thorough preliminary research to gain a foundational understanding of the subject matter. This involves reviewing industry standards, regulatory requirements, and any available documentation related to the technical area. I then consult with subject matter experts, leveraging their knowledge to fill in the gaps and validate my initial findings. It’s crucial to ask targeted questions that draw out not just the what, but the how and why of the processes in question.
I rely on established auditing frameworks, such as COSO or COBIT, which provide a structured methodology that can be adapted to various technical environments. These frameworks ensure that my approach remains systematic and comprehensive, even in unfamiliar territory. Throughout the audit process, I maintain a stance of continuous learning, adapting my inquiries as my understanding deepens. I meticulously document all findings, ensuring that the audit trail is clear and that any conclusions drawn are well-supported by evidence.
In past experiences, this structured yet flexible approach has allowed me to successfully navigate audits in new technical arenas. By combining a solid research foundation with expert insights and a robust framework, I’ve been able to deliver comprehensive audit results that withstand scrutiny and add value to the organization.”
6. Share an example of how you’ve handled resistance from auditees during an audit.
Frequently, internal auditors encounter resistance from auditees, which can manifest as skepticism, defensiveness, or outright opposition. Candidates must navigate this delicate balance with thoroughness and maintain cooperative relationships while ensuring the audit achieves its objectives.
When responding, it is advisable to recount a specific instance that demonstrates your diplomatic skills and your approach to handling objections or pushback. Outline the steps you took to understand the auditee’s concerns, provide clear explanations of the audit process and its importance, and how you managed to work collaboratively to resolve the issue. Highlight your ability to remain professional and constructive despite any resistance, emphasizing any positive outcomes that resulted from your approach.
Example: “ In one instance, during a routine financial audit, I encountered resistance from a department that was wary of the auditing process, perceiving it as an intrusive evaluation rather than an opportunity for improvement. Recognizing their concerns, I initiated a meeting with the department head to discuss the specific areas of apprehension. By actively listening to their issues, I was able to understand that their resistance stemmed from a lack of clarity about the audit’s objectives and potential implications for their team.
To address this, I provided a succinct overview of the audit process, emphasizing its role in enhancing the organization’s efficiency and the value it could bring to their operations. I reassured them that the audit was not designed to assign blame but to identify areas for improvement and to support the department in implementing best practices. Through this dialogue, we established a mutual understanding and set the stage for a collaborative relationship. As the audit progressed, I made sure to communicate findings promptly and discuss potential recommendations in a constructive manner, which helped to build trust and ensure that the department was engaged in the process. The result was not only a successful audit with valuable insights but also a strengthened relationship with the department that facilitated smoother audits in the future.”
7. Outline your strategy for staying current with changes in auditing standards and regulations.
Staying abreast of the ever-evolving landscape of auditing standards and regulations is a task auditors must embrace to ensure the integrity of financial reporting and risk management practices. Candidates should have a systematic approach to continuous learning and adaptation to maintain competency.
When responding, candidates should outline a clear, actionable strategy that includes regular review of publications from relevant accounting and auditing boards, participation in continuing professional education (CPE), active membership in professional organizations, and engagement with a network of professionals for insights and updates. They might also mention attending industry conferences, webinars, and workshops. It’s important to express a commitment to lifelong learning and to demonstrate an understanding of how staying current with auditing standards and regulations is crucial for the auditor’s role in safeguarding the organization’s financial and operational integrity.
Example: “ To ensure I remain current with auditing standards and regulations, I maintain a structured approach that involves a combination of proactive self-study and active engagement with the professional community. I regularly review updates from the International Auditing and Assurance Standards Board (IAASB), the Financial Accounting Standards Board (FASB), and the Public Company Accounting Oversight Board (PCAOB), as these entities frequently release new standards and guidance that impact audit practices.
In addition to self-study, I am committed to continuing professional education (CPE) by enrolling in courses that focus on recent changes in auditing standards and emerging issues in the field. This commitment extends to participating in webinars, workshops, and industry conferences, which not only provide insights into the practical application of new standards but also offer opportunities to discuss challenges and best practices with peers. Furthermore, I leverage my memberships in professional organizations such as the Institute of Internal Auditors (IIA) to access a wealth of resources, including industry publications, and to network with other professionals who can offer diverse perspectives on navigating regulatory changes. This multifaceted strategy ensures that I am well-equipped to uphold the highest standards of audit quality and compliance.”
8. How do you prioritize tasks when managing multiple audit assignments simultaneously?
Due to the dynamic nature of the work, effective prioritization is essential within internal audit roles. Auditors must evaluate the urgency and importance of each task, allocate resources wisely, and adapt to changing circumstances without sacrificing audit quality.
When responding to this question, a candidate should outline their system for assessing the significance of each assignment, perhaps referencing a specific prioritization framework like the Eisenhower Matrix or a risk-based approach. They could then explain how they balance deadlines, available resources, and potential impact on the company, providing concrete examples of how they have successfully navigated such challenges in the past. It’s also beneficial to mention how communication and transparency with team members and stakeholders play a role in their prioritization strategy.
Example: “ In managing multiple audit assignments, I adopt a risk-based prioritization approach, aligning tasks with the organization’s strategic objectives and potential risk exposure. I evaluate the significance of each audit by assessing factors such as the materiality of the area being audited, the complexity of the operations, the potential for financial impact, and any regulatory compliance implications. This assessment allows me to allocate resources effectively and determine the urgency of each assignment.
I then sequence tasks using a combination of deadline-driven scheduling and the flexibility to adjust as new information emerges. Communication is key; I maintain ongoing dialogue with stakeholders and audit team members to ensure transparency and adaptability. For instance, while leading concurrent audits, I identified a regulatory change that significantly increased the risk profile of one project. I swiftly reallocated resources to address this elevated risk, ensuring compliance and minimizing potential financial repercussions, while keeping all parties informed and adjusting timelines for other assignments as necessary. This dynamic approach ensures that the most critical risks are addressed promptly while still meeting all deadlines.”
9. What’s your experience with implementing recommendations post-audit?
The true value of an audit lies in the improvements made as a result. Candidates must demonstrate their ability to influence management to take action, manage follow-up effectively, and ensure that recommendations are actively implemented to strengthen the organization.
When responding, candidates should share specific examples of past audits where their recommendations were adopted. They should detail the steps taken to communicate findings to management, the strategies employed to persuade and ensure buy-in, and the methods used to track the implementation process. Emphasis should be placed on collaboration, clear communication, and the ability to work with different departments to achieve a common goal. Quantifiable results, such as improvements in efficiency, reduced costs, or mitigated risks, will underscore the impact of their involvement.
Example: “ In implementing recommendations post-audit, I have consistently prioritized clear communication and collaboration with stakeholders to ensure that findings are not only understood but also acted upon effectively. For instance, after identifying a significant gap in the financial control framework during a routine audit, I developed a detailed remediation plan. This plan not only outlined the necessary corrective actions but also provided a realistic timeline and resource allocation for the management team.
To secure buy-in, I facilitated a series of workshops with the relevant departments, where we reviewed the audit findings and discussed the rationale behind each recommendation. By involving them in the solution development process, I ensured that the recommendations were practical and tailored to the operational realities of the business. Post-implementation, I established a tracking mechanism using key performance indicators to monitor the progress and efficacy of the changes. This approach led to a 20% reduction in process inefficiencies and a significant decrease in compliance-related incidents, demonstrating the tangible benefits of the audit recommendations.”
10. Tell us about a particularly challenging audit report you wrote and how it was received.
Dissecting complex financial landscapes and translating findings into comprehensive reports is a key skill for internal auditors. They must handle complexity and potential conflict with a balance between thoroughness and diplomacy.
When responding, focus on outlining the challenge, such as the complexity of the issue, the stakes involved, or the resistance anticipated. Detail your approach to the audit, emphasizing your analytical and investigative process. Then, describe how you crafted the report to be clear and professional, and discuss the strategies you used to ensure its constructive reception, such as stakeholder engagement or follow-up discussions. It’s crucial to reflect on what you learned from the experience and how it has honed your auditing acumen.
Example: “ In a recent audit, I encountered a complex situation involving intricate inter-departmental transactions that had significant implications for financial reporting and compliance. The challenge was not only in the technical accounting aspects but also in navigating the sensitive political landscape within the organization, as the findings had the potential to impact reputations and inter-departmental relationships.
To address this, I conducted a thorough investigation, meticulously tracing transactions and corroborating evidence, while maintaining open communication with all stakeholders to ensure transparency. In crafting the report, I focused on clarity and objectivity, presenting the facts and their implications in a manner that was both comprehensive and accessible. I included actionable recommendations that balanced the need for compliance with an understanding of operational realities.
The report was initially met with some resistance due to the potential consequences of the findings. However, by facilitating a series of follow-up discussions and workshops, I helped stakeholders understand the importance of addressing the issues identified. This collaborative approach not only smoothed the reception of the report but also fostered a culture of continuous improvement. The experience reinforced the importance of empathy and communication in internal audit, skills that I have since integrated into my practice to enhance stakeholder engagement and the overall effectiveness of audit activities.”
11. Which metrics do you consider most critical when performing a financial audit?
Selecting the most critical metrics is a testament to an auditor’s ability to distill complex data into actionable insights. Candidates must understand the business’s key performance indicators (KPIs), risk assessment capabilities, and prioritization skills.
When responding, candidates should outline their approach to choosing metrics, which might include liquidity ratios, profitability ratios, and other financial KPIs that align with the company’s specific industry standards and regulatory landscape. They should also demonstrate an understanding of how these metrics can signal the financial stability and long-term viability of the organization. Providing examples from past audits where certain metrics provided crucial insights would further illustrate their competency and strategic thinking in this area.
Example: “ When performing a financial audit, I prioritize metrics that offer a comprehensive view of the organization’s financial health. Liquidity ratios, such as the current ratio and quick ratio, are essential for assessing the company’s ability to meet short-term obligations. Profitability ratios, including gross profit margin, operating margin, and return on assets, are critical for evaluating the efficiency and effectiveness of management’s use of resources. Additionally, I consider leverage ratios like debt-to-equity and interest coverage ratios to understand the company’s financial structure and risk exposure.
In one instance, while analyzing a company’s financial statements, I identified a declining trend in its quick ratio, which was not immediately apparent to the management. This insight prompted a deeper investigation into the company’s receivables and inventory turnover, revealing inefficiencies in cash management and inventory control. By bringing these issues to light, the company was able to implement corrective measures, ultimately improving its liquidity position and operational performance. This example underscores the importance of selecting the right metrics to uncover underlying financial issues that could affect the organization’s long-term sustainability.”
12. Describe a situation where you had to audit a highly complex process; how did you proceed?
A meticulous mind is required to understand and unravel tangled procedures, identify risks, and provide actionable insights to improve efficiency and compliance. Employers assess a candidate’s analytical skills and ability to handle challenging tasks that demand high-level problem-solving and critical thinking.
When responding to this question, outline a structured approach starting with a thorough review of documentation to understand the process flow. Emphasize the importance of breaking down the process into manageable parts, using data analytics tools if appropriate, and engaging with key stakeholders to gain insights. Discuss how you prioritize areas of highest risk or complexity and how you keep your knowledge current in a rapidly changing regulatory environment. Highlight your communication skills when explaining complex issues to non-auditors and how you ensure your findings lead to constructive recommendations and improvements.
Example: “ In auditing a highly complex process, my initial step was to conduct an exhaustive review of the existing documentation to gain a comprehensive understanding of the process flow. This involved analyzing process maps, control descriptions, and relevant policies and procedures. Recognizing the intricacies of the process, I segmented it into more manageable components, which allowed me to identify and focus on areas of higher risk and complexity.
To enhance the efficiency of the audit, I utilized data analytics tools to scrutinize transactional data and control logs, which provided quantitative insights into the process’s performance and any anomalies. Throughout the audit, I maintained close communication with key stakeholders to validate my understanding and to gather their perspectives on operational challenges and control effectiveness. This collaborative approach not only enriched the quality of my audit findings but also fostered a constructive environment for discussing potential improvements.
Upon concluding the audit, I synthesized the complex technical details into clear, actionable insights for the management team. My recommendations were tailored to address the root causes of any issues uncovered and to strengthen the overall control environment. I ensured that my communication was both precise and accessible, enabling stakeholders without an audit background to grasp the significance of the findings and the value of the proposed enhancements. This approach not only facilitated immediate remedial action but also contributed to the continuous improvement of the process.”
13. What is your process for verifying the reliability of information provided by other departments?
Maintaining objectivity and systematically scrutinizing information is crucial for auditors, ensuring their work is not compromised by inaccuracies or bias. Candidates must demonstrate their toolkit for cross-checking facts and figures and their persistence in pursuing the truth.
When responding, it’s important to articulate a structured approach that typically involves cross-referencing data with multiple sources, using analytical procedures, and understanding the internal controls that govern the information’s accuracy. You should highlight your attention to detail, your understanding of audit standards, and your experience with specific techniques such as sampling, reconciliations, and discussions with relevant personnel to gain a comprehensive understanding of the data’s reliability. Demonstrating your commitment to continuous learning and staying updated with the latest audit technologies and practices will also reinforce your capability in this crucial aspect of the role.
Example: “ To verify the reliability of information provided by other departments, I initiate my process by understanding the internal controls in place that pertain to the data generation and reporting mechanisms. This involves reviewing control design and testing control effectiveness to ensure they are operating as intended. Subsequently, I employ analytical procedures to assess the data for expected trends and anomalies.
If inconsistencies arise, I delve deeper through substantive testing, which includes examining source documents, conducting reconciliations, and performing data sampling. Throughout this process, I maintain open communication with the relevant department personnel to clarify any ambiguities and to understand the context behind the data. This multi-layered approach, grounded in a strong grasp of audit standards and a detail-oriented mindset, ensures a thorough validation of the information’s accuracy and reliability.”
14. How do you handle confidential information discovered during audits?
Demonstrating discretion and adherence to ethical standards is a non-negotiable aspect of the job for internal auditors. They must navigate the intricacies of what can, should, or must be disclosed, and to whom, under varying circumstances.
When responding to this question, highlight your understanding of relevant laws, regulations, and company policies governing the protection of confidential information. Detail your experience with handling sensitive data, emphasizing a systematic approach to maintaining confidentiality. Share specific strategies or protocols you follow to safeguard information, such as secure storage, limited access, and proper disposal methods. It’s also important to mention how you would address potential breaches and the communication channels you would use to report issues without compromising confidentiality.
Example: “ In managing confidential information uncovered during audits, I adhere strictly to the relevant legal frameworks, such as the Sarbanes-Oxley Act, and industry-specific regulations like HIPAA for healthcare-related data. My approach is to classify data according to its sensitivity and apply corresponding controls. For instance, I ensure that all sensitive documents are encrypted and stored in secure, access-controlled environments. Access to this information is logged and monitored, with entry limited to authorized personnel only.
In the event of identifying a potential breach, I follow a predefined incident response plan that prioritizes containment and assessment, without disclosing sensitive details outside of the necessary channels. Communication regarding the breach is handled through secure and official means, ensuring that only those who need to know are informed, and that they receive just enough information to perform their role in the resolution process. This systematic approach to confidentiality is continuously reviewed and updated to align with evolving best practices and regulatory requirements.”
15. Illustrate your method for assessing IT controls within an organization.
Ensuring an organization’s IT controls are effective, current, and compliant with relevant standards and regulations is a pivotal role for internal auditors. They must demonstrate a systematic, thorough approach that shows an understanding of IT risks and the ability to identify control weaknesses.
When responding, outline a structured process that begins with planning and understanding the company’s IT environment. Discuss how you would identify the key IT controls, map them against risk assessments, and perform tests to evaluate their effectiveness. Highlight your ability to use both manual and automated testing techniques and your familiarity with industry best practices and frameworks such as COBIT or ISO/IEC 27001. It’s essential to convey that your method is not just about finding faults but also about providing value by recommending enhancements that align with the organization’s strategic objectives.
Example: “ In assessing IT controls, I initiate with a thorough planning phase, which involves gaining a deep understanding of the organization’s IT environment, including its infrastructure, applications, and data. This is complemented by reviewing the organization’s objectives, IT strategy, and risk landscape. I then identify and prioritize key IT controls that mitigate the most significant risks, ensuring alignment with frameworks such as COBIT or ISO/IEC 27001.
Subsequently, I execute a combination of manual and automated testing procedures to evaluate the effectiveness of these controls. This includes walkthroughs, inspections, and the use of specialized software to perform data analysis and identify anomalies. For each control, I assess both the design and operational effectiveness, considering not only compliance with policies and procedures but also the control’s ability to withstand emerging threats and changes in the IT environment.
The culmination of this process is a report that not only details the findings and gaps but also provides actionable recommendations for improvement. These recommendations are tailored to enhance the resilience of the IT control environment while supporting the organization’s strategic goals, ensuring that the audit adds value beyond mere compliance.”
16. What innovative techniques have you applied to improve the efficiency of internal audits?
Innovation in audit techniques reflects a candidate’s ability to enhance traditional processes with new ideas or technology. It shows a forward-thinking mindset and a commitment to continuous improvement in a field that’s becoming increasingly complex and data-driven.
When responding, a candidate should highlight specific examples of innovative practices they’ve incorporated, such as the use of data analytics tools, automation software, or new methodologies for risk assessment. They should explain how these techniques have led to more accurate, comprehensive audits and how they’ve streamlined processes, reduced costs, or improved the audit team’s ability to provide actionable insights to management. Quantifying the benefits of these innovations, when possible, will underscore their practical impact.
Example: “ In enhancing the efficiency of internal audits, I’ve leveraged advanced data analytics tools to mine and analyze large datasets, enabling us to identify trends and anomalies that manual processes might overlook. By integrating these tools into our audit procedures, we’ve significantly reduced the time spent on data collection and analysis, allowing us to focus on higher-risk areas and strategic insights. This approach has not only expedited the audit cycle but also improved the precision of our findings.
Additionally, I’ve adopted automation software for routine audit tasks, such as control testing and compliance checks. This has freed up valuable auditor time, shifting our resources from repetitive tasks to more complex and judgment-intensive areas of the audit. As a result, we’ve seen a measurable decrease in the audit cycle time by 30%, while simultaneously enhancing the coverage and depth of our audits. The introduction of these innovative techniques has also facilitated a more proactive risk management stance, providing management with real-time insights and recommendations for improving internal controls and operational efficiency.”
17. When faced with ambiguous audit findings, how do you determine the next steps?
Handling ambiguity is essential in auditing, as it often involves interpreting incomplete or conflicting data. Candidates must demonstrate critical thinking, problem-solving skills, and the ability to make judicious decisions when a straightforward answer isn’t available.
To respond effectively, you should outline a structured approach: start by explaining how you analyze the available data to identify potential explanations for the ambiguous findings. Discuss the importance of consulting with relevant stakeholders to gather more context and the criteria you use to decide if further investigation is warranted. Emphasize your commitment to maintaining the integrity and thoroughness of the audit process, while also demonstrating flexibility and resourcefulness in resolving uncertainties. It’s vital to convey that your approach is methodical, yet adaptable, ensuring that the audit’s objectives are met despite any ambiguities encountered.
Example: “ When faced with ambiguous audit findings, my first step is to conduct a thorough analysis of the data to identify any patterns or inconsistencies that could point toward potential explanations. This involves a deep dive into the audit trail, looking at transaction histories, and cross-referencing with related records to understand the context of the discrepancies. I prioritize this initial analysis to ensure that any follow-up actions are data-driven and targeted.
Following the data analysis, I engage with relevant stakeholders to gather additional insights. This may include interviewing process owners, reviewing procedures with the compliance team, or discussing potential system errors with IT support. The insights from these discussions are crucial for piecing together the puzzle. If these steps do not resolve the ambiguity, I assess the materiality and risk of the findings to decide if a more detailed investigation is warranted. This decision is based on the potential impact on the financial statements and the risk to the organization, ensuring that the audit process remains focused and efficient. Throughout, I maintain a balance between thoroughness and pragmatism, ensuring that the integrity of the audit is upheld without expending unnecessary resources on issues that may not have a material effect on the audit’s conclusions.”
18. Provide an example of a time when you uncovered fraud during an audit; how was it addressed?
Detecting fraud is a testament to an auditor’s expertise and understanding of complex accounting systems. Candidates must show their experience in identifying fraudulent activities and their approach to handling sensitive situations with appropriate protocols.
When responding, candidates should recount a specific incident where they identified discrepancies that indicated fraud. They should detail the steps taken to investigate the issue, maintain impartiality, and ensure that due process was followed. It’s crucial to highlight the communication with the relevant departments or authorities, the action taken to address the fraud, and the measures implemented to prevent future occurrences. The response should convey professionalism, ethical standards, and the ability to act decisively in the face of wrongdoing.
Example: “ In one instance, during a routine financial audit, I identified a series of irregular transactions that exhibited classic signs of fraudulent activity. These transactions were marked by inconsistent documentation and a lack of proper authorization. Upon discovery, I maintained objectivity and followed our established protocols, initiating a confidential and thorough investigation to avoid any undue alarm or potential tampering with evidence.
I collaborated closely with the compliance department, ensuring that all investigative actions were in line with regulatory requirements and the company’s internal policies. After gathering and analyzing the evidence, which included interviewing relevant personnel and reviewing transaction histories, the suspicions of fraud were confirmed. The findings were promptly reported to senior management and the board’s audit committee. In response, they engaged with external legal counsel and law enforcement to take appropriate legal action against the individuals involved. Subsequently, I worked with the risk management team to strengthen internal controls, including enhancing monitoring systems and employee training programs, to mitigate the risk of similar fraud occurrences in the future. This experience underscored the importance of vigilance and a robust internal audit function in safeguarding the organization’s assets and integrity.”
19. How do you evaluate the effectiveness of corrective actions taken by management following an audit finding?
Ensuring that corrective actions are effective in addressing the root causes of findings is part of effective internal audit practices. Candidates should possess the analytical skills to assess the sustainability and impact of management’s responses to audit findings.
When responding to this question, outline a systematic approach that begins with understanding the original audit finding in depth. Detail how you would review the corrective action plan provided by management, ensuring it aligns with the identified risks and control gaps. Discuss the importance of setting clear metrics for success and the use of follow-up audits to verify that corrective actions have not only been implemented but have also resulted in the desired improvements. Mention any collaboration with management throughout the process and the ongoing monitoring that may be necessary to ensure the effectiveness of the actions over time.
Example: “ To evaluate the effectiveness of corrective actions taken by management following an audit finding, I first ensure a thorough understanding of the root cause of the finding. Next, I review the management’s action plan to ascertain that it adequately addresses the identified risks and control gaps. It’s essential that the response is not merely a superficial fix but a sustainable solution that mitigates the risk of recurrence.
I then establish clear, quantifiable metrics for success, which are crucial for measuring the effectiveness of the implemented changes. These metrics are derived from the expected outcomes that the corrective actions aim to achieve. Subsequently, I conduct follow-up audits to gather evidence that the corrective measures have been enacted and are functioning as intended. This involves not only a point-in-time assessment but also a consideration of the longevity and resilience of the improvements. Continuous dialogue with management is vital throughout this process to ensure that any adjustments to the action plan are made in a timely manner and that the changes are embedded within the organization’s processes and culture. This ongoing monitoring is critical to confirm that the corrective actions continue to be effective over time.”
20. What role do you believe internal audit plays in corporate governance?
Assessing the effectiveness of risk management, control, and governance processes is the function of an organization’s internal audit. Candidates should grasp the strategic significance of the role, perceiving it as a proactive element in steering the company towards ethical practices and operational excellence.
When responding to this question, candidates should articulate their understanding of internal audit as a critical component that supports the board and management in carrying out their responsibilities. They should stress the value of internal audit in enhancing and protecting organizational value by providing risk-based and objective assurance, advice, and insight. Moreover, a good response would include examples of how internal audit can contribute to the organization’s success by identifying operational inefficiencies, financial misreporting, or strategic misalignments, and by suggesting improvements.
Example: “ Internal audit is a cornerstone of robust corporate governance, acting as an independent and objective assurance function that evaluates and improves the effectiveness of risk management, control, and governance processes. By systematically reviewing and assessing the adequacy of internal controls, the internal audit provides the board and senior management with critical insights into the organization’s risk profile and compliance status. This, in turn, empowers them to make informed decisions and to ensure that the organization operates within the bounds of applicable laws, regulations, and internal policies.
Through its work, internal audit identifies potential areas of operational inefficiency, financial misreporting, and strategic misalignment, which could undermine the organization’s objectives. By bringing these issues to light and recommending enhancements, internal audit adds value by not only protecting assets but also by facilitating the optimization of resources and the alignment of strategies with organizational goals. For instance, in a previous audit of procurement processes, the identification of bottlenecks and non-compliance with procurement policies led to a redesign of the process, resulting in both cost savings and a reduction in procurement cycle time, thereby directly contributing to the organization’s operational efficiency and bottom line.”
Top 20 Pharmaceutical Marketing Interview Questions & Answers
Top 20 psychoanalysis interview questions & answers, you may also be interested in..., top 20 proofreading interview questions & answers, top 20 customer segmentation interview questions & answers, top 20 ethics interview questions & answers, top 20 stakeholder interview questions & answers.
- Knowledge hub
- Corporate Governance
- Industry News
- Inside Apollo Solutions
Audit case studies: lessons from real-world audit failures and success stories
If you’re an auditor, you’ve probably achieved your fair share of success stories – perhaps ...
By Tom Edwards & Yasmin Wilks
If you’re an auditor, you’ve probably achieved your fair share of success stories – perhaps you’ve witnessed a few failures too.
As the saying goes, we learn from our mistakes, and audit case studies, both failures and successes serve as valuable insight. Real-life audit examples provide us with lessons on what to do and what to avoid, enabling organisations to improve their audit processes.
Ready to discover some real-world examples? Here’s our pick of a few high-profile cases…
When things go wrong
(1) enron corporation.
The Enron scandal and the subsequent collapse of the Enron Corporation serves as a stark reminder of audit failure and corporate misconduct. Possibly the most high-profile scandal ever unearthed, the Sarbanes-Oxley Act (SOX) of 2002 was passed as a result of scandals such as this, WorldCom, Tyco, and Global Crossing.
Enron's auditor Arthur Andersen was heavily criticised for failing to detect fraudulent financial reporting. And lots of lessons can be learned from this example.
Firstly, Enron’s case highlights the importance of auditors maintaining independence from the companies they audit to ensure unbiased assessments. But it also reminds us of the importance of whistle-blower protection – where there are safeguards in place, organisations will encourage openness and provide the confidence for individuals discovering financial irregularities to expose them. And Enron finally emphasises how crucial regulatory oversight is in holding auditors accountable and preventing corporate fraud.
(2) Toshiba
We’ve all heard of Toshiba , a renowned multinational conglomerate, manufacturing a wide variety of consumer and business products. Despite the company’s famous success, this chapter of their story is not one of their finest.
In July 2015, Toshiba experienced an internal audit failure that spotlighted the gap between good corporate governance structure and its practical implementation. It led to Toshiba Corp’s president, Hisao Tanaka, and his two predecessors quitting after investigators found that the company had inflated earnings by $1.2 billion between 2009 and 2014.
Regardless of a sound governance structure, the organisation suffered from a massive financial scandal, highlighting the importance of proactive internal auditing to identify and prevent financial irregularities.
(3) Ernst & Young
Even the largest professional services companies are sometimes at the centre of an audit scandal. And in the case of Ernst & Young , these kinds of scenarios serve as a reminder of the importance of a robust auditing process for even the biggest of players.
EY was fined $11.8 million for audit failures in 2016. USA regulator SEC found that EY’s audit team repeatedly failed to detect fraudulent activity for more than four consecutive years. Additionally, it was reported that EY’s team failed to take effective measures in minimising known recurring tax-related problems.
This case emphasises the critical role auditors play in scrutinising high-risk areas and addressing known deficiencies. And underscores the importance of due diligence and thoroughness in audits.
(4) WorldCom
The WorldCom scandal is another example of a colossal audit failure. Arthur Andersen, the same auditor implicated in the Enron scandal, failed to detect a massive accounting fraud at WorldCom.
What can we learn from this tale? Well, attentive auditing is essential, and auditors need to exercise a blend of vigilance and scepticism when assessing financial statements. This example also points to ethical responsibility, underscoring auditors’ moral and ethical duty to report financial irregularities.
Like Enron, WorldCom’s case was instrumental in regulatory reforms, like the Sarbanes-Oxley Act which increased corporate accountability.
Getting it right
(1) apple inc.
Tech giant Apple is widely recognised for its financial transparency and internal controls. Their financial audits consistently reflect strong performance and accountability. Key takeaways from Apple's success include their transparency – Apple publishes detailed financial statements and reports that are easily accessible to the public, building trust with investors and stakeholders. They also have a set of robust internal controls and processes in place, minimising the risk of financial mismanagement or fraud.
The organisation’s MD Tim Cook says , “We do the right thing, even when it’s not easy.”
(2) Microsoft
Microsoft's another great example of a business with transparency and accountability at its core. The tech leader has consistently demonstrated exemplary corporate governance and financial reporting .
Their success highlights several valuable lessons, including the significance of disclosure. Microsoft provides comprehensive financial disclosures, offering investors a clear picture of their financial health. And they’ve also got their finger on the pulse when it comes to risk management , with practices in place that have been instrumental in ensuring long-term financial stability.
Microsoft carries out consistent and regular financial audits , to maintain trust and transparency with all of their stakeholders.
(3) Johnson & Johnson
Johnson & Johnson's another example of a profound commitment to transparency . The healthcare multinational is renowned for its sense of responsibility when it comes to ethical conduct.
Key takeaways include their strong ethical leadership – an essential asset for fostering a culture of compliance and accountability.
They also boast hardy compliance programs , proving that investing in this area can help detect and prevent financial misconduct. Stakeholder communication is another factor in Johnson & Johnson’s audit success, and open comms are encouraged to build trust and confidence.
What can we learn from all these case studies? The need for thoroughness, vigilance, transparency, ethical leadership, and continual improvement in auditing are essential. They emphasise the importance of not just having a good corporate governance structure, but also ensuring its effective implementation. And by learning from both successes and failures, we can strive to build a corporate environment that prioritises (financial) integrity and compliance with relevant regulatory, legal, and industry standards – and, of course foster trust and prevent costly failures.
Are you looking for high-calibre talent with the skills to protect you from audit mishaps? Let’s chat about your needs. Or perhaps you’re an audit professional looking to help companies grow their audit capabilities? If you’re looking to progress your career and safeguard an exciting, growing business, get in touch , or check out our latest roles .
Related Posts
Sign up to our newsletter
Ready to get started.
- Cookie Policy
- Privacy Policy
- Terms & Conditions
Upload your CV today!
Case Studies
Who: Holbrook Tool & Molding: What do you know about ISO 13485:2016 What: Holbrook Tool & Molding certified their quality management system intending to demonstrate compliance with applicable FDA requirements and ISO 13485:2016. Problem: In their quest for growth in the medical device industry, Holbrook Tool & Molding decided to leverage their ISO 9001:2015 certification and gain an ISO 13485:2016 certification. However, ISO 13485:2016 clauses were not updated to ISO 9001:2015 version. Solution: Since ISO 13485:2016 follows ISO 9001:2008 clauses, it was decided to update this version which was already updated for the release of ISO 9001:2015. A quality manual was developed with less than five work instructions and training was given to different levels of the organization. Since then, internal audits have been conducted and continue today. Result: Fourteen years later, the Quality Manager can successfully maintain and improve a combined ISO 9001 and ISO 13485 quality system. Ownership and commitment have been enabled throughout the organization as the system is now easier to understand.
Who: Holbrook Tool & Molding: A one-size quality manual does not fit all What: A quality management system was developed to enable the client to quickly respond to customers, solve problems faster and support their initiative to eliminate quality-based problems. Problem: In their quest for QS-9000 certification, a previous consulting company handed them an off-the-shelf, 100-page quality manual and 20 procedures – which the client could not possibly maintain. Solution: A policy and procedure quality manual was developed with less than five work instructions. Appropriate training and guidance training were provided to different levels of the organization. Result: Fourteen years later, the Quality Manager was able to successfully maintain and improve the quality management system. Ownership and commitment were enabled throughout the organization as the system is now easier to understand. Holbrook Tool & Molding can maintain their ISO 9001 certification with no findings and no customer requested corrective actions for repetitive years.
Who: Bra-Vor: One good turn deserves another What: A quality management system was developed to enable the client to quickly respond to customers, solve problems faster and support their initiative to eliminate quality-based problems. Problem: Based on a referral from Holbrook Tool & Molding, Bra-Vor also enlisted IQPS to pursue QS-9000 certification and then ISO-9000 certification. Solution: A policy and procedure quality manual was developed with less than five work instructions. Appropriate training was provided to different levels of the organization. Guidance was also provided on effective management reviews. Internal audits were conducted and continue today. Result: Fifteen years later, the Quality Manager was able to successfully maintain and improve the quality management system. Bra-Vor can maintain its ISO 9001 certification with no findings and no customer requested corrective actions for repetitive years.
Who: Baxter Machine Product: There are two kinds of people – complexifiers and simplifiers What: A quality management system was developed to enable the client to quickly respond to customers, solve problems faster and support their initiative to eliminate quality-based problems. Problem: A former employee developed a 100-page quality manual and 20 procedures – which was impossible to maintain. Solution: A policy and procedure quality manual was developed with less than five work instructions. Appropriate training and guidance were provided to different levels of the organization. Subsequently, an environmental management system (ISO 14001) was integrated into the quality management system (ISO 9001) and morphed into a business management system.
Result: Ownership and commitment were enabled throughout the organization as it is now easier to understand. Baxter Machine Product can maintain both ISO certifications with no findings and no customer requested corrective actions or incidents for many years.
Who: Blair Strip Steel: If you can’t beat us, join us What: Blair Strip had an established quality system and needed someone to perform its internal audits. After an accredited surveillance audit, Blair Strip Stell hired IQPS to perform internal audits based on QS-9000. Problem: Blair Strip had one person in their quality department performing many tasks, which made it hard to maintain independence and expertise. Solution: The Quality System was upgraded to TS-16949 and integrated with ISO 14001, and internal audits continued to be conducted. Result: Eighteen years later, the Quality Manager can still maintain and improve the quality management system. Blair Strip can maintain its TS-16949 certification with minimal to no findings, and no customers requested corrective actions.
Who: Belleflex: Join us too! What: A new startup company owned by Blair Strip needed to implement a quality management system and obtain ISO-9001 certification as soon as possible. Problem: The Bellflex Quality Manager needed guidance in machine shop implementation. Solution: IQPS provided guidance through discussions regarding best practices, reviews of the system documentation, and appropriate training for all levels of Bellflex.
Result: After six months of startup, Belleflex successfully obtained an ISO-9001 certification. Their quality system and performance were recognized by NASA as an approved supplier to produce parts for the International Space Station.
Who Blind and Vision Rehabilitation Services of Pittsburgh: We need another consultant What: A quality management system was developed to allow them to quickly respond to customers, solve problems, and eliminate quality-based problems. Problem A previous consultant left them an unfinished quality manual with 20 procedures- which was impossible to maintain. They also needed an ISO-9001 certification to fulfill a Pennsylvania Department of Transportation (PennDOT) supplier requirement.
Solution A policy and procedure quality manual was developed with only one work instruction for office staff. Appropriate training and guidance were provided to different levels of the organization. Internal audits were conducted and continue today. Result Seven years later, the quality system is easily maintained by staff members and the Operations Manager. Blind and Vision Rehabilitation Services of Pittsburgh was recognized as one of the top three non-profit organizations for 2013.
Academia.edu no longer supports Internet Explorer.
To browse Academia.edu and the wider internet faster and more securely, please take a few seconds to upgrade your browser .
Enter the email address you signed up with and we'll email you a reset link.
- We're Hiring!
- Help Center
Download Free PDF
AUDIT AND ASSURANCE CASE STUDY QUESTIONS
The first article in this series of two on Paper P7 case study questions discussed question style, what to look for in the requirements, how higherlevel skills are tested, and the meaning of professional marks within a question requirement. This second article goes through part of a typical Section A case study question, applying the recommended approach described in the previous article. This approach comprises four stages. STAGE 1 – UNDERSTANDING THE REQUIREMENT The first thing to do is to read and fully understand the question requirement. Here is the requirement we will be looking at in this article: 'Prepare a report, to be used by a partner in your firm, in which you identify and evaluate the professional, ethical, and other issues raised in deciding whether to accept the appointment as provider of an assurance opinion as requested by Petsupply Co.' (12 marks) Note: this requirement includes two professional marks. Having read the requirement, break it down. You are asked to do two things: identify, ie state from the information provided evaluate, ie discuss from a critical point of view. The requirement asks you to consider 'professional, ethical, and other issues'. This could cover a wide range of considerations, such as: ethics: independence, competence, conflicts of interest, confidentiality, assessing integrity professional issues: the risk profile of the work requested, the fee – and whether it is sufficient to compensate for high risk, availability of staff, managing client expectations, logistical matters such as timing, legal and regulatory matters – such as money laundering, and (in some cases) obtaining professional clearance other issues: whether the work 'fits' with the commercial strategy of the audit firm, the potential knockon effect of taking on the work – such as the impact on other clients, or on other work performed for this client. You are asked to produce a report, so remember that the professional marks available will be awarded for using the correct format, the use of professional business language, and for presenting your comments as a logical flow culminating in a conclusion. From reading the requirement, you know that the question scenario will be based on a potential assurance assignment and will be broadly based around acceptance issues. STAGE 2 – READING THE SCENARIO When reading through the detail of the scenario, you should now be alert to information relevant to this requirement. Highlight important points that you think are relevant to the scenario and remember to focus on issues that could affect your acceptance of a potential assurance assignment.
Related papers
1. The Role of the Public Accountant in the American Economy 2. Professional Standards 3. Professional Ethics 4. Legal Liability of CPAs 5. Audit Evidence and Documentation 6. Planning the Audit Linking Audit Procedures to Risk Appendix A Selected Internet Addresses Appendix B Examples of Fraud Risk Factors Appendix C Illustrative Audit Case 7. Internal Control Appendix A Antifraud Programs and Control Measures 8. Consideration of Internal Control in an Information Technology Environment 9. Audit Sampling Appendix A Probability-Proportion-to-Size Sampling Appendix B Audit Risk 10. Cash and Financial Investments 11. Accounts Receivable, Notes Receivable, and Revenue Appendix A Illustrative Audit Case Appendix B Illustrative Audit Case 12. Inventories and Cost of Goods Sold 13. Property, Plant, and Equipment: Depreciation and Depletion 14. Accounts Payable and Other Liabilities Appendix A Illustrative Audit Cases 15. Debt and Equity Capital 16. Auditing Operations and Completing the A...
This study developed and tested a model that describes how auditors evaluate the relevant risks and how auditors adapt to these risks when they decided to accept their clients. Client acceptance model developed by the auditor is intended for auditors to evaluate the risk associated with business clients, including the financial condition of the internal control structure of the client and the client's prospects and business continuity. This evaluation is then used to determine the risks that would be faced by the auditor if the auditor will accept the audit assignment for a client company or reject consideration of profitability or letigasi possibility in the future. Participants or respondents in this study are the Under Graduate final semester accounting students who enrolled in the Accounting Department of Soegijapranata Catholic University in Semarang. There were 345 students. The method of data analysis used in this study is SEM (Structural Equation Modeling), which will be...
Our case study focuses on developing the student's understanding of the auditor's evaluation of prospective audit clients. A comprehensive evaluation is uniquely important since the client acceptance decision can be the chief contributor to auditor business risk (engagement risk). Even so, guidance in the area of client acceptance is general in nature and not as extensive or prescriptive as other significant auditing promulgation. This student case study provides practical evaluation criteria for client acceptance that can also be used by accounting professionals to benchmark their client acceptance evaluation process. This student case study can be used in the accounting classroom as a descriptive benchmark of the evaluation of a prospective client. STUDENT ENGAGEMENT USING A CASE STUDY his case can be implemented in the advanced auditing course as a take home problem or as an in-class discussion. We recommend motivating the topic of client acceptance by asking students if more revenue from a potential new audit client engagement is always a good thing. The answer is seemingly simple-'yes, of course more revenue is better than less revenue.' We suggest posing the following set of questions to students: Put yourself in the place of an audit partner of a mid-size accounting firm who is under pressure to bring in new client work to grow the CPA practice and increase revenue. Is more business always a good thing? Why or why not? According to professional guidance, what are the evaluation criteria you need to consider before taking on a new audit client or new client work? Of course, the answer to these questions is not simple. Our Case Analysis and Discussion follows.
Studies in Business and Economics, 2010
Prashastya Research Journal, 2021
This study is an attempt to show the issues faced by the auditors-practicing Chartered Accountants. Study is made within Belagavi city. The objective of the study resembles the topic of this paper-to find out the issues faces by the auditors and to understand those issues. The Primary data is collected in the form of questionnaire and oral interview. Secondary data is collected through CA Institute and references for audit theory. Comparison and analyses are made through charts and tables to understand the issues faced by auditors in Belagavi City. There are various facets of the study which explores the practical issues and has no thematic solution in the theory of auditing and any statute. Theoretically speaking, the Indian system of auditing is an excellent system which is carried out by professionals and it is very hard for the client organization/firm to find any loophole in it. But, does not have solutions to basic problems faced by the auditors which are discussed in this study. Yet, this study aims at just pointing out the persistent issues in the profession of auditing. Considering the issues, respondents, that are practicing auditors, have given solutions and are stated in the article.
European Journal of Accounting, Finance & Business
Department of accountancy, the malawi polytechnic, 2017
Internal audit function plays a major role in achieving organizational goals. Internal audit functions need to be operated effectively in order to add value to the organisation. Internal auditors help in identifying risks and inefficiencies in organisation and recommend controls to mitigate those risks. The study aimed to assess factors that would contribute to an effective internal audit function in Malawian commercial banks. The objectives were to assess the extent of internal auditor’s competency; to examine the extent of internal auditor’s independence and objectivity and to identify the level of improvement in the financial performance of commercial banks operating in Malawi. The study adopted descriptive design. It targeted 40 personnel from all the commercial banks by selecting 4 people from each bank. The main focus was 2 individuals from the internal audit function; 1 from risk department; and 1 from management. Purposive sampling was employed and questionnaires were used. The study revealed that there is a high correlation between the factors assessed and effectiveness of an internal audit function. The study also found that the function doesn’t only satisfy the legal need to have internal audit function in commercial banks but it also adds value.
Loading Preview
Sorry, preview is currently unavailable. You can download the paper by clicking the button above.
Economia Seria Management, 2009
Ovidius University Annals: Economic Sciences Series, 2017
AFRICA DEVELOPMENT AND RESOURCES RESEARCH INSTITUTE (ADRRI) JOURNAL, 2021
Asian Review of Accounting, 2008
Managerial Auditing Journal, 1998
The British Accounting Review, 1996
Proceedings of the 3rd International Conference of Business, Accounting, and Economics, ICBAE 2022, 10-11 August 2022, Purwokerto, Central Java, Indonesia, 2022
Advances in Scientific and Applied Accounting, 2012
International Journal of Auditing, 2005
The International Journal of Academic Research in Business and Social Sciences, 2011
American Journal of Evaluation, 1989
Journal of Governance, Taxation and Auditing
Proceedings of the 2nd International Conference on Economic Education and Entrepreneurship, 2017
AFRE (Accounting and Financial Review), 2020
- We're Hiring!
- Help Center
- Find new research papers in:
- Health Sciences
- Earth Sciences
- Cognitive Science
- Mathematics
- Computer Science
- Academia ©2024
Case Studies
Login to favorite
A collaborative effort of the Anti-Fraud Collaboration, these case studies are educational tools for all members of the financial reporting supply chain, as well as students. Participants in case study teachings start with a hypothetical scenario about a fictional company dealing with a fraud. Guided by an instructor, they then discuss what could have been done to address the situation.
Browse Resources
Comment Letter
Meeting Highlights
Publications
More Collections
Access to audit personnel grant program, audit committee, audit committee insights, audit committees, audit quality, audit quality indicators, auditor reporting.
Auditors & ESG Information
Audits of Brokers and Dealers
Caq symposium, classroom and training resources, collective action in the fight against fraud, connecting auditors and academics, cybersecurity, diversity and inclusion.
Effective Disclosure
Emerging Technologies
Ensuring reliability, quality, and independence in public company audits, fair value accounting, future talent, independent standard setting, international practices task force inflation discussion documents, international practices task force meeting highlights, mandatory firm rotation, policymakers, public policy & technical alert, research advisory board grant program, risk assessment panel discussion, role of the auditor, sarbanes-oxley, sec regulations committee highlights, snapshot alert, the caq at aaa, the future of corporate reporting, the value of auditor independence, transparency of audits, video vignettes.
The CAQ, in connection with the Auditing Section of the AAA, established a program designed to facilitate accounting and auditing academics’ ability to obtain access to audit firm personnel to participate in their research projects.
EXPLORE MORE
Publications 04.05.21
Fraud and Emerging Tech: Artificial Intelligence and Machine Learning
Comment Letter 02.01.21
IAASB: Discussion Paper, Fraud and Going Concern in an Audit of Financial Statements
Publications 01.12.21
Mitigating the Risk of Common Fraud Schemes
Policymakers across the globe increasingly recognize the vital role of audit committees and their importance to audit quality. In close collaboration with partner organizations, the CAQ is actively engaged in policy developments related to audit committees.
Newsletter 03.24.23
Audit Committee Insights | March 2023
Publications 03.22.23
Audit Quality Reports Analysis: A Year in Review
Video 02.28.23
Audit Committee Effectiveness: A Webinar Series
Audit Committee members are an essential component to the health of our financial reporting ecosystem and capital markets. While our economy is constantly evolving, so is the role of audit committee members. Policymakers, investors, and other leaders across the globe increasingly recognize the vital role of audit committees and their importance to audit quality. In close collaboration with partner organizations, the CAQ is actively engaged in developments that impact audit committees and provides valuable resources, current policy information, and tools to support audit committees with their responsibilities.
Auditors are highly skilled at adapting and problem solving, without sacrificing the audit quality on which our capital markets and investors depend. It is no surprise that under unprecedented circumstances, long-term investments in training and technology enabled the profession to quickly transition to remote work. Many factors lead to a quality audit, but a combination of auditor expertise and independence coupled with constant innovation and technology bolsters the level of trust and confidence in company financial statements and forms the basis of audit quality—and, therefore, value to capital markets.
2021 Audit Committee Transparency Barometer
Auditor Independence: A Cornerstone of Audit Quality
How Audits Support Capital Markets
The CAQ has been at the forefront of the movement to develop quantitative and qualitative metrics regarding the audit—commonly referred to as audit quality indicators (AQIs)—that could be used to better inform audit committees about key matters that may contribute to the quality of an audit.
Publications 11.30.22
2022 Audit Committee Transparency Barometer
Engaging constructively with policymakers and key stakeholders, the CAQ and its members have made substantial and practical contributions to ongoing efforts to enhance information presented in the auditor’s report to investors and other users.
Newsletter 01.07.21
Public Policy and Technical Alert, December 2020
Alert 12.07.20
Public Policy and Technical Alert, November 2020
Auditors play a key role as independent gatekeepers in the financial reporting ecosystem that underpins confidence in capital markets. Auditors build trust and confidence in information through the assurance services they provide. The auditing profession has steadily developed, systemized, and strengthened this trust and confidence-building role in providing assurance related to company financial statements and internal control over financial reporting. While auditors will continue the essential work of auditing historical financial statements, they can also bring their ability to enhance trust and confidence in other types of data and information issued by companies.
The Role of Auditors in Company-Prepared ESG Information: A Deeper Dive on Assurance
The Role of Auditors in Company-Prepared Cybersecurity Information: Present and Future
The Role of Auditors in Non-GAAP Financial Measures and Key Performance Indicators: Present and Future
Lending trust and credibility to ESG information.
Comment Letter 06.17.22
SEC Proposed Rule: The Enhancement and Standardization of Climate-Related Disclosures for Investors
Video 03.07.22
ESG Reporting 101: What is ESG assurance and why does it matter?
CAQ Commentary on SEC Climate-Related Disclosure Proposal
Alert 12.07.21
Audit Planning Alert for Auditors of Brokers and Dealers
Alert 08.27.19
CAQ ALERT #2019-01 – PCAOB REPORT ON 2018 INSPECTIONS OF BROKERS AND DEALERS
Alert 08.22.18
CAQ Alert #2018-04 – Broker’s and Dealer’s Use of a Service Organization
The Annual CAQ Symposium brings together practice leaders and audit research scholars for a discussion of important issues and an exploration of how research can inform those issues. On the pages for each event, find videos, summaries, and panel participants.
CAQ Symposium 2022
Video 10.28.21
What’s happening in ESG reporting & assurance today? Top 5 Takeaways from CAQ Symposium 2021
CAQ Symposium 2021
The CAQ creates educational videos that can be used in the classroom or as training resources. Available videos include a “Video Vignettes” series that provides a view into the types of conversations that take place during an audit. Videos also include classroom-ready excerpts derived from an expert panel at a CAQ event.
Publications 01.17.23
2023 Profession Outlook
Publications 03.07.22
Demonstrating the Value of Public Company Auditors
Statement 11.03.21
Statement of Support for the International Sustainability Standards Board (ISSB)
Strong fraud deterrence and detection requires all participants in the financial reporting ecosystem to exercise extreme vigilance. In a heightened risk environment regulators, internal and external auditors, audit committees, and public company management must work together to effectively detect and deter fraud.
Since its inception, the CAQ has sought to improve audit quality by increasing engagement between auditors and the academic community by fostering independent research related to the public company auditing profession.
Audit firms, standard-setters, regulators and the CAQ are developing a growing number of resources to help auditors, investors, management and audit committees understand the impact of the COVID-19 pandemic on financial reporting and oversight, and the CAQ is working to curate and distill that information for you.
COVID-19 11.09.20
Anti-Fraud Resources
COVID-19 10.06.20
Auditing Profession Resources
COVID-19 06.19.20
Audit Committee Resources
Cybersecurity threats are complex and an evolving issue with serious implications for public companies, their boards, investors, and other stakeholders, making it critical that the public company auditing profession does their part to support companies, boards, and others in addressing such threats.
Publications 06.27.22
Audit Partner Pulse Survey, Q2 2022
Comment Letter 05.09.22
SEC: Cybersecurity Risk Management, Strategy, Governance, and Incident Disclosure
Bold Ambition
Accounting+
Video 10.19.21
Profession in Focus: Diversity in Focus with Elena Richards
The CAQ is a prominent voice in the discussion about effective financial disclosures. Convening key investor and financial groups, the CAQ has developed concrete recommendations on ways to facilitate investors’ access to meaningful information.
Comment Letter 11.25.19
SEC: Update of Statistical Disclosures for Bank and Savings and Loan Registrants
Comment Letter 07.29.19
SEC: Amendments to Financial Disclosures about Acquired and Disposed Businesses
Video 11.20.18
Audit Committee Reporting – Leslie Murphy
Emerging technologies are altering the financial reporting environment substantially, and this change is accelerating. For auditors and others in financial reporting, the CAQ provides insights on the benefits and risks of technology developments.
Publications 05.16.19
Emerging Technologies, Risk, and the Auditor’s Focus: A Resource for Auditors, Audit Committees, and Management
Publications 01.12.20
Fraud and Emerging Tech: Robotic Process Automation
Video 04.09.19
Evolution in Auditing
The CAQ is dedicated to enhancing investor confidence by supporting the public company auditing profession every day to improve audit quality and enhance auditor independence, creating a solid foundation of financial reporting that benefits investors in the United States.
2020 Audit Committee Transparency Barometer
Audit In Action
The CAQ has engaged on the issue of fair value (or mark-to-market) accounting, regarding both its usage broadly in the markets and in the context of auditing fair value measurements.
Alert 03.02.18
Public Policy and Technical Alert, February 2018
Publications 03.12.09
CAQ Testimony: “Mark-to-Market Accounting: Practices and Implications”
Meeting Highlights 06.12.97
June 1997 IPTF Joint Meeting Highlights
Are you purpose-driven? Are you a natural problem solver with an unquenchable curiosity? Are you fascinated by the inner workings of companies and financial markets? Then a career in audit may be right for you.
Video 10.05.20
Profession in Focus: A Conversation with EY’s Ken Bouyer on Inclusiveness Recruiting
Making It Balance
Robust internal control over financial reporting (ICFR) is a keystone of investor confidence. The CAQ has advanced the discussion around ICFR and produced a range of resources on the issue.
Perspectives on Management Review Controls: Challenges and Solutions
Alert 05.01.20
Public Policy and Technical Alert, April 2020
Alert 02.07.20
PUBLIC POLICY AND TECHNICAL ALERT, JANUARY 2020
In an increasingly interconnected global economy, market participants are considering whether it is possible or desirable to move toward a more uniform global “language” for financial reporting. As the discussion has taken place around International Financial Reporting Standards (IFRS), the CAQ has been an active voice.
The CAQ has been outspoken against policy provisions that would interfere with the independence of the accounting and auditing standard-setting processes.
The CAQ works to increase investor trust in the capital markets by promoting and developing high-quality performance from the public company auditing profession. A cornerstone of our strong U.S. capital markets is the trust investors place on audited financial statements when making critical decisions. Our resources provide information for investors on developments in the auditing profession, oversight and governance of public companies, and leading practices in the field of audit.
Publications 12.08.21
Value of the Audit
The CAQ has been a leading voice on the issue of mandatory audit firm rotation, which has significant implications for investors, audit committees, public company auditors, and the markets.
Comment Letter 12.14.11
PCAOB: Concept Release on Auditor Independence and Audit Firm Rotation
Comment Letter 02.14.14
ISS: Consultation Document on Auditor Ratification
Keeping CAQ members and stakeholders informed on significant public policy and accounting matters.
The CAQ and the public company auditing profession are dedicated to supporting valuable independent academic research that can have important, real-world impact on audit quality and the future of auditing.
The panel discussion videos are short excerpts from a CAQ event where practitioners and a leading academic provide perspectives on various issues related to the auditors’ risk assessment of a company. Included are the panelist bios and free short descriptions of each video excerpt.
Video 01.09.18
How Auditors Approach Risk Assessments
Video 01.08.18
How Materiality Impacts the Auditor’s Risk Assessment
Video 01.07.18
Consideration of Risks in Multilocation Audits
The CAQ has been at the forefront of the discussion around the role of the public company auditor and whether it should evolve to meet the changing information needs of investors.
Publications 03.09.23
The Role of the Auditor in Climate-Related Information
Publications 11.16.22
Audit Partner Pulse Survey, Fall 2022
The enactment of the Sarbanes-Oxley Act (SOX) of 2002, a law aimed at fostering more reliable financial reporting and enhancing audit quality, was a watershed moment for investors, public company auditors, and the markets. The CAQ has worked to create understanding of the impact of this important law. It has opposed efforts to weaken SOX section 404(b), which provides investors with important assurance by the independent auditor regarding management’s representations about the effectiveness of their company’s internal control over financial reporting (ICFR).
Video 08.01.19
Profession in Focus: Accelerated Filers, ICFR Audits, and Investor Protection
SEC: Amendments to the Accelerated Filer and Large Accelerated Filer Definitions
Publications 05.09.19
Guide to Internal Control Over Financial Reporting
Stay updated on the latest CAQ news.
Since 2008, the CAQ has organized and participated in panel discussions at the Annual Meeting of the American Accounting Association (AAA).
Video 10.09.20
CAQ at the AAA – August 2020
CAQ Panel at the 2020 AAA Auditing Section Midyear Meeting: Leveraging New and Old Media to Promote Degrees in Accounting
Video 08.12.19
CAQ Panel at The 2019 AAA Annual Meeting: Sustaining a Strong System of Quality Control to Enhance Audit Quality
The Sarbanes-Oxley Act of 2002 (SOX) was a watershed moment for investors, public company auditors, and capital markets. It established more reliable corporate reporting and auditor independence rules that enable stakeholders to trust the information provided by public companies. Two decades later, the U.S. is now widely recognized as the gold standard for auditor independence and thousands of high-quality audits are completed each year.
Video 08.08.22
Pop-Up Conversation with Rep. Brad Sherman (D-Calif.) and Mark Baer of Crowe
Video 07.27.22
SOX: The Evolution of Corporate Reporting
Our capital markets are an important engine for driving and maintaining our economic and societal well-being. These markets operate on information, and audited financial statements have long been a critical element of this information dynamic for their accuracy, transparency, and reliability. As investors make decisions, they depend on the information they receive from public company management. As a result, investors need—and in fact have long sought—an independent third party to provide assurance on the information provided by company management. Independence underpins the very credibility of the audit and, ultimately, its value to capital markets. It is also one reason why audit quality in the US has never been higher.
Publications 10.20.22
Auditor Independence
How Do Auditors Maintain Independence?
Audit in Action: The Role of the Audit Committee
The CAQ has engaged on the issue of effectively enhancing transparency in the audit, endeavoring to facilitate access to meaningful information for financial statement users and other constituencies.
Video 02.05.19
Critical Audit Matters: Audit Committee Perspectives
Video 02.13.18
Key Updates on Audit Committee Transparency and Investor Confidence
Alert 10.11.17
CAQ Alert #2017-04 – Select Auditing Considerations for the 2017 Audit Cycle
The vignettes provide insights into the types of conversations that occur between audit team members, as well as between auditors and preparers. The discussions captured in the videos can also be used in other teaching situations, as they highlight communications and interviewing techniques, professional skepticism, and how to navigate conversations on difficult and sensitive issues.
Video 04.13.17
Vignette 3: Auditing Is a People Business
Video 02.17.17
Vignette 2: Evaluating Root Cause and Severity of a Control Deficiency
Video 08.16.16
Vignette 1: Evaluating Management Review Controls over a Goodwill Impairment Estimate
The latest news and resources from the CAQ.
Stay Connected.
To read this content please select one of the options below:
Please note you do not have access to teaching notes, the impact of auditors creating flowcharts on auditors’ understanding of the flow of transactions and internal control evaluation.
Managerial Auditing Journal
ISSN : 0268-6902
Article publication date: 26 September 2024
Motivated by the importance of gaining an understanding of the flow of transactions when assessing the effectiveness of internal controls for Sarbanes–Oxley Act (SOX) compliance, concerns raised by the Public Company Accounting Oversight Board (PCAOB) of audit firm deficiencies in these areas and auditors’ use of both narratives and flowcharts to document the flow of transactions, this article aims to examine the impact of auditors creating flowcharts versus narratives on auditors’ transaction flow understanding and internal control evaluation performance.
Design/methodology/approach
This paper conducts a between-participants experiment examining auditor-created flowcharts versus narratives and different levels of documentation quality on auditors’ understanding of the flow of transactions and internal control evaluation performance.
This paper finds that auditors who create flowcharts gain a better understanding of the clients’ transaction flow and perform better on internal control evaluations than auditors who create narratives. Process results from a moderated-mediation model also show a moderating effect of quality and mediating effect of understanding.
Practical implications
These findings inform PCAOB policy decisions and inspection efforts and audit firms’ quality and process improvement efforts by providing initial support for having auditors create flowcharts to improve their understanding of the flow of transactions and internal control evaluation performance.
Originality/value
To the best of the authors’ knowledge, this is the first study to examine the effect of auditor-created flowcharts compared to narratives on auditors’ understanding of the flow of transactions and internal control evaluation performance.
- Internal control over financial reporting
- Business process modeling
- Audit quality
Acknowledgements
The authors thank Uday Murthy, Patrick Wheeler and Lisa Gaynor for valuable comments and suggestions. The authors also thank research workshop participants at the University of South Florida and audience participants at the Florida Accounting Behavioral Research Symposium for helpful comments on an early version of this paper. The authors gratefully acknowledge the comments and suggestions from the anonymous reviewers and James Bierstaker (associate editor).
Perols, R.R. and Perols, J.L. (2024), "The impact of auditors creating flowcharts on auditors’ understanding of the flow of transactions and internal control evaluation", Managerial Auditing Journal , Vol. ahead-of-print No. ahead-of-print. https://doi.org/10.1108/MAJ-10-2023-4094
Emerald Publishing Limited
Copyright © 2024, Emerald Publishing Limited
Related articles
All feedback is valuable.
Please share your general feedback
Report an issue or find answers to frequently asked questions
Contact Customer Support
COMMENTS
a. Costs and benefits. Incorrect. Costs and benefits are the same when exer-cising due professional care in assurance services and consulting services. b. Complexity of work. Incorrect. Complexity of work is the same when exer-cising due professional care is assurance services and consulting services. c. Extent of work.
Table of Contents. 1) Questions on Understanding ISO 9001 requirements. 2) Risk-based Thinking and Context of the Organisation Questions. 3) Questions on Leadership and Commitment in Internal Audit. 4) Questions on Planning and Objectives in Internal Audit. 5) Questions on Operation and performance evaluation. 6) Conclusion.
How to approach Advanced Audit and Assurance. The first article in this series of two on Paper P7 case study questions discussed question style, what to look for in the requirements, how higher-level skills are tested, and the meaning of professional marks within a question requirement. This second article goes through part of a typical Section ...
high-level description of the auditing process. The rest of this course will provide d. scriptions and examples of each of these steps.Create the conditions - Provide a structure for the internal audi. , train auditors, and show management support.Select auditors - Choose individuals who know enough about the process to conduct the.
key area for internal audit: about 10% of Practical advice for applying internal audit's resources 1 Ensure that the internal audit function has the right development practices and the right mix of people - headcount is just a number. 2 Ensure that sound recruitment processes for the internal audit team are in place. Be clear
Even though internal audit function (IAF) are an important player in internal control, however, there is little academic knowledge about their impact. Based on a single-case study in a large financial institution, this paper explores to what extent and how IAF affect internal controls. Furthermore, it assesses whether IAF add value to the company.
They examine the key topics of context and interested parties. These concepts touch every corner of the organization, and this is exactly how ISO 9001:2015 is intended to be used. Top management should be able to describe how the QMS is used to run the company, not just pass an audit. 6.
Sample Question: Take any organization of your choice and answer the following two questions (10 Marks) 1. Write Five Quality Objectives for an Organization (5 marks) 2. Write Five agenda items for a Management Review Meeting (5 marks) Sample Answer A: Note: Depending on the organization the quality objectives are set.
Domain 1: Managing the Internal Audit Function (40-50%) 1. The proper organizational role of internal auditing is to: a. Assist the external auditor in order to reduce exter nal audit fees. Incorrect. Reduc tion of external audit fees is a result of internal audit work but not a role.
C. Incorrect. Human relations and communications relate to the professional proficiency of the internal auditor. D. Correct. According to Practice Advisory 1110-1, organizational status and objectivity permit members of the internal audit activity to render the impartial and unbiased judgments essential to the proper conduct of engagements."
Quality Management Systems (QMS) & ISO 9001 - Case Studies. Implementing ISO 9001:2015 can help ensure that customers get consistent, high-quality products and services, which in turn can benefit your organization. The following ISO 9001:2015 case studies offer a look at the difference ISO 9001 can make for organizations in terms of process ...
It is likely that the combined total of the two questions will be towards the higher end of this range. Both Section A questions will be case studies. Detailed information will be provided about a business for which the candidate's firm is providing an audit or assurance service. The aim of the case study question is to place the candidate in ...
2. Describe a time when you identified a significant control weakness within an organization. Continuously searching for flaws that could undermine a company's integrity, financial health, and compliance with laws and regulations is a key responsibility of internal auditors.
Even the largest professional services companies are sometimes at the centre of an audit scandal. And in the case of Ernst & Young, these kinds of scenarios serve as a reminder of the importance of a robust auditing process for even the biggest of players. EY was fined $11.8 million for audit failures in 2016.
simpleQuE Advantage: Since 2005, the scope of work for Globe Motors has been to perform their internal audits to ISO 9001, IATF 14949®, AS9100, and ISO 14001. We provided full consulting assistance to get them certified to each of these standards, along with training in these standards. In addition to upgrading four sites to the new ISO, IATF ...
The benefits of a certified QM system according to ISO 9001 are: · Clear responsibilities. · Straightforward processes that are generally better implemented. · Greater confidence in management. · Better relationships with suppliers. · Better understanding of customer needs. · Improved leverage with regard to vis-a-vis banks and insurance ...
A quality management system was developed to enable the client to quickly respond to customers, solve problems faster and support their initiative to eliminate quality-based problems. Based on a referral from Holbrook Tool & Molding, Bra-Vor also enlisted IQPS to pursue QS-9000 certification and then ISO-9000 certification.
Abstract. Applying internal quality audit processes and procedures into higher education institutions has been under active consideration since the days of the former Higher Education Quality Council (HEQC) and the ideas have been much discussed within the Quality Assurance Agency (QAA) and by other funding agencies.
The objective of the study resembles the topic of this paper-to find out the issues faces by the auditors and to understand those issues. The Primary data is collected in the form of questionnaire and oral interview. Secondary data is collected through CA Institute and references for audit theory.
A collaborative effort of the Anti-Fraud Collaboration, these case studies are educational tools for all members of the financial reporting supply chain, as well as students. Participants in case study teachings start with a hypothetical scenario about a fictional company dealing with a fraud. Guided by an instructor, they then discuss what could have been done to address the situation.
Example: "Your business is growing, and using my internal auditing skills to help you become even more successful sounds very exciting. Your company also offers excellent benefits, and I have spoken to current employees who love the friendly atmosphere.". Related: 12 Tough Interview Questions and Answers. 2.
Purpose. Motivated by the importance of gaining an understanding of the flow of transactions when assessing the effectiveness of internal controls for Sarbanes-Oxley Act (SOX) compliance, concerns raised by the Public Company Accounting Oversight Board (PCAOB) of audit firm deficiencies in these areas and auditors' use of both narratives and flowcharts to document the flow of transactions ...